Abstract:The stress-based criteria have long been adopted as the major guideline in the design of line pipes, but for those under the displacement control, such as pipelines in seismic regions, landslide areas and subsea environment, the stress-based criteria tend to be relatively conservative, instead the strain-based criteria will be more economic and reasonable to use in the pipe design. Hence, the strain-based design methods in different international standards were summarized and compared, as well as their applicable conditions. In view of the different formulas of the ultimate compressive strain of local buckling in the standards of Norway, Canada, etc., calculations of the ultimate compressive strain were conducted under different radius-thickness ratios and design pressures. It is revealed that the Canadian standard expression and Japanese SUZUKI formula are more conservative. To meet the demand of real engineering application, it was suggested that 0.3 t/D (t refers to the pipe wall thickness; D refers to the external diameter of pipes) be adopted as a conservative estimation of the ultimate compressive strain in the absence of design pressure, and that the Canada standard expression be employed while the design pressure can not be ignored. Because the strain-based design process has not been proposed in the Chinese pipeline codes, the work of this paper can serve as a reference for the research in the relevant areas in present China.

Advances in "design by Analysis" Methods for Pressure Vessels

Plastic Analysis Methods for Design by Analysis of Pressure Vessels

Comparison of design methods for internally pressurized ellipsoidal head

A New Pressure Vessel Design by Analysis Method Avoiding Stress Categorization

Reliability Assessment of Pressure Vessel Design Methods

Analysis and Comparison of American and Japanese Fatigue Design Method of High Pressure Vessel

A study of the ultimate compressive strain of local buckling in strain-based design of pipelines

Study on Methods for the Reinforcement of Pressure Vessels with Large Openings

The Method of Design by Analysis for Cylindrical Pressure Vessels with Spherically Dished Head

Evaluation of DBA-L pressure vessel design method by 2D and 3D solid models

A New Method of Stress Linearization for Design by Analysis in Pressure Vessel Design

Discussion on the Implementation of the Primary Structure Method in Design by Analysis

Assessment of DBA-L Pressure Vessel Design Method by a Cylindrical Vessel with Hemispherical Ends

Safety analysis of pressure piping containing incomplete penetration under combined loads

Plastic Limit Load Analysis for Pressure Pipe with Incomplete Welding Defects Based on the Extended Net Section Collapse Criteria

Introduction for Design-by-analysis of CEN's Unfired Pressure Vessel

Primary structure method of stress classification for design by analysis

PLASTIC ANALYSES OF STRUCTURES AND FAILURE ASSESSMENT OF PRESSURE VESSELS AND PIPING WITH VOLUMETRIC DEFECTS

A New Design Method For Axially Loaded Thin-Walled Cylindrical Shells Based On Elasto-Plastic Buckling Analysis

Foundation of Plasticity for Design by Analysis of Pressure Vessels

Elastic-plastic Ratcheting Analysis for Pressure Vessels Based on Elastic Core Evaluation Criterion