Abstract:Ellipsoidal and torispherical heads, whose geometric shapes are close, are usually used as end closures of internally pressurized vessels. In pressure vessel codes, for example, ASME BPVC Section VIII, ellipsoidal heads are designed as torispherical heads using geometric equivalency approaches. However, the difference between ellipsoidal and equivalent torispherical heads has not been studied in detail. In this paper, we first investigate the shape deviation between the two types of heads. Then we compare the elasticplastic behaviors between ellipsoidal and equivalent torispherical heads as well as their failure modes, i.e., buckling and plastic collapse. It is found that ellipsoidal heads have more buckling resistance than equivalent torispherical heads, indicating that the current design rules for buckling failure based on the geometric equivalency approaches result in uneconomical design. Nevertheless, the shape deviation has little effect on plastic collapse pressures of ellipsoidal and equivalent torispherical heads, showing that the geometric equivalency approaches are applicablefor such heads thatfail by plastic collapse (bursting). In addition, the experimental and numerical results show that such heads experience geometric strengthening. The FE method considering the effect of geometric strengthening provides a good prediction about plastic collapse (bursting) pressure. However, the current design equation for bursting does not consider the effect ofgeometric strengthening, also leading to uneconomical design. Therefore, in order to avoid uneconomical design, we recommend that (1) with respect to the buckling of ellipsoidal heads, a new design equation be proposed rather than implementing the geometric equivalency approaches, and (2) the current design equation for bursting be deleted, and a new design equation, considering the effect of geometric strengthening, be proposed for the bursting of ellipsoidal and torispherical heads subjected to internal pressure.

Comparison of design methods for internally pressurized ellipsoidal head

A New Method for Preventing Plastic Collapse of Ellipsoidal Head under Internal Pressure

COMPARISON OF ELLIPSOIDAL AND EQUIVALENT TORISPHERICAL HEADS UNDER INTERNAL PRESSURE: BUCKLING, PLASTIC COLLAPSE AND DESIGN RULES

Analysis and Comparison of American and Japanese Fatigue Design Method of High Pressure Vessel

Comparison of the Strength Design and Prevention Method of Elephant Foot Buckling among Countries' Standards of Oil Tanks

A study of the ultimate compressive strain of local buckling in strain-based design of pipelines

Discussion on Thickness Formula of Cylindrical Shell under Internal Pressure

The Method of Design by Analysis for Cylindrical Pressure Vessels with Spherically Dished Head

A Creep Buckling Design Method of Elliptical Heads Based on the External Pressure Chart

Experimental Investigation on Buckling of Ellipsoidal Head of Steel Nuclear Containment

Advances in "design by Analysis" Methods for Pressure Vessels

A new formula to predict buckling pressure of steel ellipsoidal head under internal pressure

Comparison of Standards and Regulations for Pressure Vessels Constructed from Spheroidal Graphite Cast Iron Between Native and Abroad

Elastoplastic Analysis of Novel Parabola-Arc-Shaped Head for Internal Pressure Vessel

Analytical Study on the Buckling of Cylindrical Shells with Stepwise Variable Thickness Subjected to Uniform External Pressure

Effect of Shape Imperfection on the Buckling of Large-Scale Thin-Walled Ellipsoidal Head in Steel Nuclear Containment

Comparison of Specification Method and Analysis Method for Fracture Prevention Analysis of Reactor Vessel

Limit pressure and design criterion of cylindrical pressure vessels with nozzles

Investigation on the Plastic Deformation During the Stamping of Ellipsoidal Heads for Pressure Vessels

A New Design Method For Axially Loaded Thin-Walled Cylindrical Shells Based On Elasto-Plastic Buckling Analysis

Study for the Structural Design of Subsea High Pressure Shell Based on ASME Code