Mu Zongsan's Misinterpretations of Kant's Self and Mind

DENG Xiao-mang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1001-9839.2006.05.001
2006-01-01
Abstract:This article,which is one of the four dealing with Mu Zongsan's misinterpretations of Kant,discusses three issues.The first one is concerned with Mu Zongsan's misinterpretation of Kant's conception of "self consciousness" or "mind",pointing out that,from the perspective of Chinese philosophy,which neglects selfreflection and independent personality,Mu Zongsan denies the reality of Kant's empirical self-consciousness as well as his transcendental self subjective activity,and he came to the conclusion that it is merely a substance of value.The second issue states that the self-denying of conscience proposed by Mu Zongsan does not take on the significance of Kantian and Hegelian self-limitation and self-negation,but works as an expediency under certain circumstances,from which scientific rationality and scientific spirit would not arise.Additionally,it has no clear-cut boundary with the traditional philosophical view that Confucianism is responsible for external but legalism for the internal.Mu Zongsan regards Kant's freedom and autonomy as entities,and he tries to replace them with natural Dao and ethical emotion of Chinese philosophy.It totally goes against Kant's standpoint of transcendentalism and critical reason,ignoring the elite of western reason spirit and free will of self-surpassing.The fundamental flaw of this misinterpretation lies in the arbitrary and irrational view of Xin(心) and Xing(性) in Chinese philosophy.Thus,the lack of sympathetic understanding of alien culture calls for deep reflection of Chinese researchers.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?