Failure Analysis of Cracked P110 Repaired Tubing Used for Gas Transmission
Shuxin Zhang,Faqin Xie,Xiangqing Wu,Xi Yan,Jinheng Luo,Xiaoliang Ma,Gege Su
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/ma16227151
2023-11-14
Abstract:With green and low-carbon developments in oil fields, an increasing amount of repaired oil tubing is being used as oil and gas transmission pipelines in China. However, due to differences in manufacturing standards between oil tubing and transmission pipelines, there are inevitably some issues during their use. This paper investigates a case of cracking failure in repaired oil tubing used as a gathering and transportation pipeline. The failure occurred after eight months of operation and was characterized by a circumferential crack at the male thread end of the tubing joint. To determine the root cause of the failure, a series of experiments were conducted on the oil tubing. The experiments included visual inspection, chemical composition analysis, mechanical properties testing, hardness testing, metallographic examination, and microstructure analysis. The results revealed that the thread of the cracked tubing was not tightened to the specified position; the connection between the tubing and the coupling was welded in a circumferential direction; and cracks occurred in the heat-affected zone of the weld. Chemical composition, tensile performance, and the Charpy impact of the tubing meet the requirements of API 5CT for P110 material, and no abnormalities were found in the metallographic structure. The microstructure at the weld toe of the fracture is martensite, and the hardness is 476 HV10. Based on the thermal simulation verification test, when the material of the tubing cools from 1200 °C, which is located in the coarse HAZ temperature zone, the base metal transforms into martensite with a little granular bainite, exhibiting its highest hardness value at 371 HV10, which is higher than the allowable hardness for carbon steel and indicates the material has poor weldability. The reasons for the cracking and failure of the tubing are that the P110 repaired tubing has a high carbon equivalent and poor weldability. During the welding process, martensitic structure was formed at the weld toe, and cold cracks appeared in the heat-affected zone, resulting in failure. To avoid the reoccurrence of such failure, recommendations are proposed.