Tian et al . reply
Yongjun Tian,Bo Xu,Dongli Yu,Yanming Ma,Yanbin Wang,Yingbing Jiang,Wentao Hu,Chengchun Tang,Yufei Gao,Kun Luo,Zhisheng Zhao,Li-Min Wang,Bin Wen,Julong He,Zhongyuan Liu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nature12621
IF: 64.8
2013-01-01
Nature
Abstract:Arising from N. Dubrovinskaia & L. Dubrovinsky Nature502,http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/nature12620(2013) Dubrovinskaia and Dubrovinsky 1 question the sub-grain structure and ultrahigh hardness of our nanotwinned cubic boron nitride (nt-cBN; ref. 2 ), and make the following assertions: (1) hardening related to nanotwinning in cBN has been known for tens of years, (2) our X-ray diffraction (XRD) and Raman results do not show the signatures of nanotwinning, (3) there are large wurtzite-structure boron nitride (wBN) domains present in our samples, and (4) our hardness values are unconvincing. We argue below that all these claims are incorrect.