Abstract:When encountering pressure equipment with a structural defect such as a local thinning defect (LTA), a critical question often arises regarding the safety of continued operation. This is primarily determined by the strength at the LTA zone, as it represents the weakest point of the structure. The remaining strength factor (RSF) is proposed as an indicator to evaluate the remaining strength and life of pressure equipment when a severe LTA is identified. The API 579/ASME FFS standard offers a series of practical engineering approaches for field engineers to follow, which have achieved great success. However, it has been found that the simpler Level 1 and Level 2 approaches sometimes fail to differentiate between LTAs on the inner or outer surface of the pressure equipment, yielding identical numerical processes and results. Moreover, the use of critical thickness profiles to replace the actual thickness profile in analysis can lead to overly optimistic estimation of the RSF, posing a potential danger when the RSF is close to the allowable limit. Key issues investigated in this study include: (a) discrepancies caused by the use of simplified critical thickness profiles or parabolic profiles, as API 579 suggested, on the RSF; (b) differences in RSFs when the same LTA is on the inner and outer wall; and (c) comparisons of membrane stress and bending stress, as well as their influences on the RSF at the cross-section of the vessel wall. It can be concluded with certainty that all simplified geometries (CTP and PTP) tend to underestimate the RSF and should be used with caution. Additionally, the actual remaining strength of the outer LTA was found to be slightly lower than that of the inner LTA of identical size. Therefore, when remaining life and derating for prolonged operation are of interest, finite element analysis on pressure equipment with the LTA is recommended.

Influence of whole shape error on the safety property of pressure vessel

Stresses Controllable Analysis and Optimal Design of Unique High Pressure Vessel Applied in Hydrogen Charge Station

Comparison of design methods for internally pressurized ellipsoidal head

A Numerical Study on the High-Velocity Impact Behavior of Pressure Pipes

Safety analysis of pressure piping containing incomplete penetration under combined loads

Mismatch effect on safety assessment of pressure pipe with incomplete penetration defect

Strength investigation on high pressure vessel with hemispherical head thinner than that of cylinder

Research On Safety Assessment Method For Pressure Pipe With Incomplete Welding Defects Under Complicated Loadings

Effect of Shape Imperfection on the Buckling of Large-Scale Thin-Walled Ellipsoidal Head in Steel Nuclear Containment

Calculation Error Analysis of Large-scale Flange of Pressure Vessel Based on Design Code GB150

Safety Testing and Analysis of the Header of the Drawn Boiler with a Small Diameter and a Large Wall Thickness

Advances in "design by Analysis" Methods for Pressure Vessels

Numerical Investigation on Explosion of Quick Actuating Pressure Vessels Due to Residual Pressure

Limit pressure and design criterion of cylindrical pressure vessels with nozzles

Safety Test Research of Pressure Pipes Containing Incomplete Welding Defects

Research on Pressure Measurement Model Using Surface Wave Considering Temperature Effect

Effects of thickness profile and inner/outer of localized thin area defects on the remaining strength of pressure equipment

Safety Assessment of the Junction Between a Thick Pressure Vessel Shell and a Thinner Hemispherical Head

Safety Evaluation for Upper Head and Manhole in SBA Hydration Reactor Based on Numerical Simulation

Sensitivity Analysis of Failure Probability on PTS Benchmark Problems of Pressure Vessel Using a Probabilistic Fracture Mechanics Analysis Code.

NUMERICAL SIMULATION OF THE FORMING PROCESS OF PRESSURE VESSEL HEADS WITH SKIRT