Anti-reflection coating with mullite and Duroid for large-diameter cryogenic sapphire and alumina optics

Kana Sakaguri,Masaya Hasegawa,Yuki Sakurai,Junna Sugiyama,Nicole Farias,Charles Hill,Bradley R. Johnson,Kuniaki Konishi,Akito Kusaka,Adrian T. Lee,Tomotake Matsumura,Edward J. Wollack,Junji Yumoto

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1364/AO.515508

2023-12-19

Abstract:We developed a broadband two-layer anti-reflection (AR) coating for use on a sapphire half-wave plate (HWP) and an alumina infrared (IR) filter for the cosmic microwave background (CMB) polarimetry. Measuring the faint CMB B-mode signals requires maximizing the number of photons reaching the detectors and minimizing spurious polarization due to reflection with an off-axis incident angle. Sapphire and alumina have high refractive indices of 3.1 and are highly reflective without an AR coating. This paper presents the design, fabrication, quality control, and measured performance of an AR coating using thermally-sprayed mullite and Duroid 5880LZ. This technology enables large optical elements with diameters of 600 mm. We also present a newly developed thermography-based nondestructive quality control technique, which is key to assuring good adhesion and preventing delamination when thermal cycling. We demonstrate the average reflectance of about 2.6% (0.9%) for two observing bands centered at 90/150 (220/280) GHz. At room temperature, the average transmittance of a 105 mm square test sample at 220/280 GHz is 83%, and it will increase to 90% at 100 K, attributed to reduced absorption losses. Therefore, our developed layering technique has proved effective for 220/280 GHz applications, particularly in addressing dielectric loss concerns. This AR coating technology has been deployed in the cryogenic HWP and IR filters of the Simons Array and the Simons observatory experiments and applies to future experiments such as CMB-S4.

Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to develop a broadband double - layer anti - reflection (AR) coating for large - diameter cryogenic sapphire half - wave plates (HWPs) and alumina infrared (IR) filters, which are used in cosmic microwave background (CMB) polarization measurements. Specifically, the paper addresses the following key issues:

1. **Maximize the number of photons reaching the detector**: In order to measure the faint CMB B - mode signal, photon losses due to reflection need to be minimized. The refractive indices of sapphire and alumina are as high as 3.1, and without an AR coating, they will highly reflect light, resulting in about 40% of the light being reflected.

2. **Minimize spurious polarization caused by off - axis incidence angles**: Off - axis incidence angles can lead to different reflectivities for different polarization states, causing intensity - to - polarization (I - to - P) leakage. This leakage is one of the main obstacles in CMB polarization measurements, especially when measuring the B - mode polarization caused by primordial gravitational waves.

3. **Meet the challenges of large - size optical elements**: This research targets large - size optical elements with a diameter of up to 600 mm, which makes it very challenging to uniformly coat AR coatings. In addition, the coating must be effective in a wide frequency band and remain stable in a low - temperature environment, avoiding delamination during the thermal cycling process.

4. **Increase transmittance and reduce absorption losses**: At room temperature, the average transmittance of the AR coating is 83%, and at a low temperature of 100 K, the transmittance increases to 90%, mainly due to the reduction of absorption losses. Therefore, the developed AR coating technology is particularly suitable for applications at 220/280 GHz, especially for solving the dielectric loss problem.

5. **Ensure coating quality control**: In order to ensure the quality of the coating, the research team has developed a non - destructive quality control technique based on thermal imaging to ensure good adhesion and prevent delamination during the thermal cycling process.

Through the above measures, this research has successfully reduced the reflectivity to about 2.6% (in the 90/150 GHz observation band) and 0.9% (in the 220/280 GHz observation band), and has been applied in the Simons Array and Simons Observatory experiments, and also provided technical support for the future CMB - S4 experiment.

### Summary

The main objective of this paper is to develop an efficient broadband double - layer anti - reflection coating to improve the accuracy and reliability of CMB polarization measurements, especially when dealing with large - diameter cryogenic sapphire and alumina optical elements, and to solve key problems in terms of reflection, transmittance, and quality control.