Abstract:Objective In this experimental work we compared the determination of absorbed dose to water using four ionization chambers (ICs), a PTW-34045 Advanced Markus, a PTW-34001 Roos, an IBA-PPC05 and a PTW-30012 Farmer, irradiated under the same conditions in one continuous- and in two pulsed-scanned proton beams. Approach The ICs were positioned at 2 cm depth in a water phantom in four square-field single-energy scanned-proton beams with nominal energies between 80 MeV and 220 MeV and in the middle of 10x10x10 cm3 dose cubes centered at 10 cm or 12.5 cm depth in water. The water-equivalent thickness (WET) of the entrance window and the effective point of measurement was considered when positioning the plane parallel (PP) ICs and the cylindrical ICs, respectively. To reduce uncertainties, all ICs were calibrated at the same primary standards laboratory. We used the beam quality (kQ) correction factors for the ICs under investigation from IAEA TRS-398, the newly calculated Monte Carlo (MC) values and the anticipated IAEA TRS-398 updated recommendations. Main results Dose differences among the four ICs ranged between 1.5% and 3.7% using both the TRS-398 and the newly recommended kQ values. The spread among the chambers is reduced with the newly kQ values. The largest differences were observed between the rest of the ICs and the IBA-PPC05 IC, measuring lower dose with the IBA-PPC05. Significance We provide experimental data comparing different types of chambers in different proton beam qualities. The observed dose differences between the ICs appear to be related to inconsistencies in the determination of the kQ values. For PP ICs, MC studies account for the physical thickness of the entrance window rather than the WET. The additional energy loss that the wall material invokes is not negligible for the IBA-PPC05 and might partially explain the low kQ values determined for this IC. To resolve this inconsistency and to benchmark MC values, kQ values measured using calorimetry are needed.

Measurement of average mass attenuation coefficient of air for 137 Cs gamma-ray irradiation beam

Absolute Measurement of Air Kerma by Graphite Pancake Ionization Chamber Exposed to 60 Co Gamma Ray

Air kerma reference field with high energy photons using a 15 MeV electron beam from a clinical linear accelerator

Monte CarIo SimuIation of PhysicaI Parameters for Air Kerma Measurement by Graphite Pancake Ionization Chamber

Comparison of the standards for absorbed dose to water of the IAEA and the KRISS, Korea in accelerator photon beams

Cavity ionization chamber responses in the JAEA and the NMIJ high-energy photon reference fields for radiation protection

Measurement of the Wall Correction Factor of a Spherical-cylindrical Cavity Ionization Chamber

Nanodosimetric investigation of the track structure of therapeutic carbon ion radiation. Part 1: Measurement of ionization cluster size distributions

Investigation of Ionization Chamber Characteristics for Ultrahigh-dose-rate Scanned Carbon-ion Beams

A New Apparatus for On-Site Calibration of Gamma Dose Rate Monitors

Experimental comparison of cylindrical and plane parallel ionization chambers for reference dosimetry in continuous and pulsed scanned proton beams

Determination of Correction Factors for Small Field Based on Measurement and Numerical Calculation using Cylindrical Ionization Chambers

Key comparison BIPM.RI(I)-K5 of the air-kerma standards of the CIEMAT, Spain and the BIPM in 137 Cs gamma radiation

Microdosimetry of a clinical carbon-ion pencil beam at MedAustron -- Part 1: experimental characterization

Assessment of four dose calculation algorithms using IAEA-TECDOC-1583 with medium dependency correction factor (K med ) application

Radiation attenuation characterization of some biological samples by using the Klein–Nishina formula

A study on 85Kr measurement with an internal gas proportional counter

X-ray spectrometry for calculating conversion coefficients from air kerma to operational quantities in radiation protection

Carrier gas attenuation in gamma assay of radioactive xenon samples

Modeling the Biophysical Effects in a Carbon Beam Delivery Line using Monte Carlo Simulation

Monte-Carlo Calculation and Measurement of Wall Correction Factor for Spherical Graphite Ionization Chamber