Co-Design as Enabling Factor for Patient-Centred Healthcare: A Bibliometric Literature Review
Sofia Silvola,Umberto Restelli,Marzia Bonfanti,Davide Croce
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/CEOR.S403243
2023-05-17
ClinicoEconomics and Outcomes Research
Abstract:Sofia Silvola, 1, 2 Umberto Restelli, 1, 3 Marzia Bonfanti, 1 Davide Croce 1 1 LIUC - Università Cattaneo, Castellanza, VA, Italy; 2 Department of Public Health Medicine, School of Health System & Public Health, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Pretoria, Pretoria, South Africa; 3 School of Public Health, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa Correspondence: Sofia Silvola, Tel +39 0331 572 509, Email Service design and in particular co-design are approaches able to align with the need of healthcare contexts of value-based and patient-centered processing through a participatory design of services. The purpose of this study is to identify the characteristics of co-design and its applicability to the reengineering of healthcare services, as well as to detect the peculiarities of the application of this approach in different geographical contexts. The methodology applied for the review, Systematic Literature Network Analysis (SLNA), combines qualitative and quantitative perspectives. In detail, the analysis applied the paper citation networks and the co-word network analysis to detect the main research trends over time and to identify the most relevant publications. The results of the analysis highlight the backbone of literature on the application of co-design in healthcare as well as the advantages and the critical factors of the approach. Three main literature streams emerged concerning the integration of the approach at meso and micro level, the implementation of co-design at mega and macro level, and the impacts on non-clinical related outcomes. Moreover, the findings underline differences in co-design in terms of impacts and success factors in developed countries and economies in transition or developing countries. The analysis shows the potentially added value of the application of a participatory approach to the design and redesign of healthcare services both at different levels of the healthcare organization and in the contexts of developed countries and economies in transition or developing countries. The evidence also highlights potentialities and critical success factors of the application of co-design in healthcare services redesign. Keywords: co-creation, co-production, systematic literature network analysis, healthcare services The healthcare context is characterized by continuous innovations and changes in treatments and diagnostics, while care processes undergo only small changes. 1 To ensure quality and efficiency in healthcare, however, it is not enough to introduce innovations, but it is necessary to analyse and revise the entire service, which includes healthcare but also non-healthcare activities. This consideration should be discussed within increasingly complex healthcare systems. These are characterized by the presence of a growing multitude of actors and a gradual transition towards an integrated organizational/managerial approach capable of facing complexities and multi-morbidities. 2 Given the shifting of the healthcare paradigm to a patient-centred and value-based medicine, a holistic approach to the review of healthcare services is essential. The core idea related to value-based healthcare is that organization and management of care should be driven by value generation for the patients. 3–5 This renewed approach includes the patient's perspective and experience in service redesign, moving from a passive role of the users to a participative one. 6–8 Service design fits into this context as a multidisciplinary approach capable of capturing the needs of stakeholders and including them in the design of multi-component services. 1 From a value-based healthcare perspective, this approach finds a perfect matching as it is capable of organizing services by working on optimization. Service design is not just about creating new services, but it is also used to reorganize existing ones. In this context, participatory design, also known as co-design, co-production, or co-creation, is a methodological approach that is applied to the development of health services through the empowerment of the various subjects involved in the pathways of interest. The application of this approach has potential advantages in quality and social terms. 9,10 Co-design also consists in the substantial involvement of experienced or potential users in the redesign processes. This approach moves from the traditional involvement of the user and caregivers in the customer satisfaction phase only, understood as the activity of completing a questionnaire to signal satisfaction with the service received and limited to the reporting of subjective perceptions, towards an approach of total involvement in the p -Abstract Truncated-