Optical Setup for Error Compensation in a Laser Triangulation System

Patrick Kienle,Lorena Batarilo,Markus Akgül,Michael H Köhler,Kun Wang,Martin Jakobi,Alexander W Koch,Michael H. Köhler,Alexander W. Koch
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/s20174949
IF: 3.9
2020-09-01
Sensors
Abstract:Absolute distance measurement is a field of research with a large variety of applications. Laser triangulation is a well-tested and developed technique using geometric relations to calculate the absolute distance to an object. The advantages of laser triangulation include its simple and cost-effective setup with yet a high achievable accuracy and resolution in short distances. A main problem of the technology is that even small changes of the optomechanical setup, e.g., due to thermal expansion, lead to significant measurement errors. Therefore, in this work, we introduce an optical setup containing only a beam splitter and a mirror, which splits the laser into a measurement beam and a reference beam. The reference beam can then be used to compensate for different error sources, such as laser beam dithering or shifts of the measurement setup due to the thermal expansion of the components. The effectiveness of this setup is proven by extensive simulations and measurements. The compensation setup improves the deviation in static measurements by up to 75%, whereas the measurement uncertainty at a distance of 1 m can be reduced to 85 μm. Consequently, this compensation setup can improve the accuracy of classical laser triangulation devices and make them more robust against changes in environmental conditions.
engineering, electrical & electronic,chemistry, analytical,instruments & instrumentation
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to solve the measurement error problem in the Laser Triangulation System (LTS), especially the significant measurement errors caused by small changes in the opto - mechanical device (such as thermal expansion). To solve this problem, the author proposes a new optical compensation setup, which divides the laser into a measurement beam and a reference beam by introducing a beam splitter and a mirror. The reference beam is used to compensate for various error sources, such as laser beam jitter or the offset of the measurement device caused by the thermal expansion of components. ### Specific problem description 1. **Measurement errors caused by small changes**: Even very small changes in the opto - mechanical device (e.g., thermal expansion) can lead to significant measurement errors. 2. **Limitations of existing solutions**: Existing compensation methods are either too complicated or can only compensate for specific parts of the error sources and cannot comprehensively solve the problem. ### Proposed solution The optical compensation setup proposed by the author includes: - **Beam splitter**: Divides the laser into a measurement beam and a reference beam. - **Mirror**: Guides the path of the reference beam. The main advantages of this setup are: - **Simple and without moving parts**: Only uses standard optical components and does not rely on complex active or moving parts. - **Compensation for multiple error sources**: Can simultaneously compensate for errors caused by laser beam jitter, changes in air refractive index, and thermal expansion of the opto - mechanical device. ### Experimental verification The effectiveness of this compensation setup has been verified through experiments: - **Static measurement**: Static measurements were carried out at a distance of 1 meter for 36 hours, and the results showed that the long - term measurement error after compensation was reduced by 75%. - **Temperature influence test**: Temperature changes were simulated by heating resistors, and the results showed that the error after compensation was reduced by 97%. ### Summary This compensation setup can significantly improve the accuracy of classical laser triangulation equipment and make it more robust to changes in environmental conditions. By introducing simple optical components, effective compensation for multiple error sources is achieved, thereby improving the stability and reliability of the system. ### Key formulas In laser triangulation, the calculation formula for the unknown distance \(d\) is: \[ d=\frac{f}{\cos\alpha}\left(1 + \sqrt{b^{2}+\left(b\cdot\tan\alpha-\frac{f}{\cos\alpha}\right)^{2}}\right)\frac{1}{v_{L}+v_{\text{offset}}}-b\cdot\tan\alpha + l_{z}\] where: - \(b\) is the base distance (in the x - direction) between the laser and the center of the lens, - \(f\) is the focal length of the lens, - \(v_{\text{offset}}\) is the offset of the detector edge in the \(v\) direction, - \(\alpha\) is the tilt angle of the lens, - \(v_{L}\) is the central position of the laser spot on the detector. The calculation formula for the compensated error \(\Delta d_{\text{comp}}\) is: \[ \Delta d_{\text{comp}}=\Delta d_{\text{meas}}-k\cdot\Delta d_{\text{ref}}\] where \(k\) is the compensation factor, usually set to 1. ### Conclusion This research effectively solves the problems of multiple error sources in the laser triangulation system by introducing a simple optical compensation setup, improving the measurement accuracy and the robustness of the system.