How Reproducible Are Surface Areas Calculated from the BET Equation? (adv. Mater. 27/2022)

Johannes Osterrieth,James Rampersad,David Madden,Nakul Rampal,Luka Skorić,Bethany Connolly,Mark D. Allendorf,Vitalie Stavila,Jonathan L. Snider,Rob Ameloot,João Marreiros,Conchi O. Ania,Diana Azevêdo,Enrique Vilarrasa‐García,Bianca Ferreira dos Santos,Xian‐He Bu,Ze Chang,Hana Bunzen,Neil R. Champness,Sarah L. Griffin,Banglin Chen,Rui‐Biao Lin,Benoît Coasne,Seth M. Cohen,Jessica C. Moreton,Yamil J. Colón,Linjiang Chen,Rob Clowes,François‐Xavier Coudert,Yong Cui,Bang Hou,Deanna M. D’Alessandro,Patrick W. Doheny,Mircea Dincă,Chenyue Sun,Christian J. Doonan,Michael T. Huxley,Jack D. Evans,Paolo Falcaro,Raffaele Riccò,Omar K. Farha,Karam B. Idrees,Timur İslamoğlu,Pingyun Feng,Huajun Yang,Ross S. Forgan,Dominic Bara,Shuhei Furukawa,Eli Sanchez,Jorge Gascón,Selvedin Telalović,Sujit K. Ghosh,Soumya Mukherjee,Matthew Hill,Sadiq Muhammad,Patricia Horcajada,Pablo Salcedo‐Abraira,Katsumi Kaneko,Radovan Kukobat,Jeff Kenvin,Seda Keskın,Susumu Kitagawa,Ken‐ichi Otake,Ryan P. Lively,Stephen J. A. DeWitt,Phillip Llewellyn,Bettina V. Lotsch,Sebastian T. Emmerling,Alexander Pütz,Carlos Martí‐Gastaldo,Natalia M. Padial,Javier Garcı́a-Martı́nez,Noemi Linares,Daniel Maspoch,José A. Suárez del Pino,Peyman Z. Moghadam,Rama Oktavian,Russel E. Morris,Paul Wheatley,Jorge A. R. Navarro,Camille Petit,David Danaci,Matthew J. Rosseinsky,Alexandros P. Katsoulidis,Martin Schröder,Xue Han,Sihai Yang⧫,Christian Serre,Georges Mouchaham,David S. Sholl,Raghuram Thyagarajan,Daniel W. Siderius,Randall Q. Snurr,Rebecca B. Goncalves,Shane G. Telfer,Seok J. Lee,Valeska P. Ting,Jemma Rowlandson,Takashi Uemura,Tomoya Iiyuka,Monique A. Van Der Veen,Davide Rega,Véronique Van Speybroeck,Sven M. J. Rogge,Aran Lamaire,Krista S. Walton,Lukas W. Bingel,Stefan Wuttke,Jacopo Andreo,Omar M. Yaghi,Bing Zhang,Cafer T. Yavuz,Thien S. Nguyen,Félix Zamora,Carmen Montoro,Hong‐Cai Zhou,Angelo Kirchon,David Fairen‐Jimenez
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/adma.202270205
IF: 29.4
2022-01-01
Advanced Materials
Abstract:Nanoporous Materials In article number 2201502, David Fairen-Jimenez and co-workers conduct a round-robin exercise by providing 18 already-measured adsorption isotherms to sixty-one labs and show that the reproducibility of the Brunauer–Emmett–Teller (BET) area determination in micro- and mesoporous materials remains a largely ignored issue. To solve this, a new computational approach—called BETSI—that expands on the Rouquerol criteria and makes an unambiguous BET area assignment possible is developed.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?