Estimates of Regulatory Interventions in Dismissal Dispute Decisions

Ben Freyens,Xiaodong Gong
2015-01-01
Abstract:The paper disentangles the effects of governments’ social values on labour courts’ adjudication of dismissal disputes in Australia. We isolate two channels by which the social values of political parties affect decisions: (i) through changes to established rules (statutory reforms) and (ii) through changes in the composition of courts (politically motivated appointments). We use a panel of 85 judges and 2876 judicial decisions meted over a 15 years time span characterized by two major legal reforms and one minor reform. We deal with selection bias by testing forand exploiting the natural randomized matching of labour court judges with unfair dismissal cases. Using several model specifications we find significant effects from both channels: statutory reforms, and judges’ work background have strong and significant effects on case outcomes, except when judges have a union work history.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?