Politics , the Judiciary , and the Arbitration of Unfair Dismissal Disputes

B. Freyens,X. Gong
2016-01-01
Abstract:The paper analyses how the social values of government affect the outcomes of dismissal dispute arbitration in Australian labour courts. We isolate two channels through which these effects materialise: statutory reforms, which change legal standards, and strategic appointments, which change court composition. We analyse the probability of plaintiff success in courts using a panel of 81 judges and 2,223 judicial decisions between 2001 and 2015. We test for and subsequently exploit the randomized matching of labour court judges with unfair dismissal cases. We also test for and address the Priest-Klein selection effect, which is known to potentially invalidate the analysis of court trials. We find significant effects from both channels: judges’ ideological background and changes to legal standards are strong predictors of case outcomes. Furthermore, we find evidence of compensating effects: judges with a progressive background rule more often in favour of dismissed employees if legal reforms adversely affect their chance of success in court.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?