Abstract:Making meaningful judgment under various uncertain situations plays an important role in our daily life. It remains unclear whether there is a general neural mechanism dealing with different types of uncertainty. Investigating the transfer of learning effects between different uncertainties paves the way to the fully understanding of this issue. Previous behavioral literatures have shown that uncertainty in decision making can originate from different sources. Converging evidences from fMRI studies have also indicated the neural correlates associated with particular types of uncertainty. In the present study, we generated a two dimensional stimulus space of Glass patterns incorporating uncertainties of criterion-based or noise-based origins and tested the transfer of the learning effect between them. For the criterion-based dimension, intermediate spiral patterns were generated by morphing between radial (0 deg of spiral angle) and concentric (90 deg of spiral angle) patterns (Li, Mayhew, & Kourtzi, 2009). For the noise-based dimension, different proportions of noise were embedded in radial and concentric patterns. We trained two groups of participants in four successive days on categorizing the Glass patterns along the criterion-based and the noise-based dimensions respectively, and tested on the uncertain stimuli of both dimensions before and after the training. Our psychophysics experiments showed that the learning effect can transfer from criterion-based dimension to noise-based dimension, but not vice versa. Especially, the transfer happened only when participants were aware of the two stimulus dimensions. Further fMRI experiment in which participants encountered both uncertainty dimensions showed that the two uncertainties activated different brain areas. That is, the criterion-based uncertainty induced more activation in ventral prefrontal cortex whereas noise-based uncertainty led to more activation in cingulated cortex. Altogether, the current results suggested that two separate but not independent neural networks are engaged in processing the different sources of uncertainty.

Asymmetrical Transfer of Learning Effects Between Signal-Based and Criterion-Based Task Uncertainties in Perceptual Decision

Learning of Uncertain Stimuli Transfers from Criterion-Based to Noise-Based Perceptual Decision, but Not Vice Versa

Learning-induced Uncertainty Reduction in Perceptual Decisions is Task-Dependent.

Hey, What is Your Choice? Uncertainty and Inconsistency Enhance Subjective Anticipation of Upcoming Information in a Social Context

Task-dependent Uncertainty Modulation of Perceptual Decisions in the Human Brain.

Cue Predictiveness and Uncertainty Determine Cue Representation During Visual Statistical Learning.

Transfer of visual perceptual learning over a task-irrelevant feature through feature-invariant representations: Behavioral experiments and model simulations

The Effect of Uncertainty on Category-Specific Attentional Orientation Was Accommodated by Shape- and Color- Dimension.

Distinct neural markers of evidence accumulation index metacognitive processing before and after simple visual decisions

Gambling in the visual periphery: a conjoint-measurement analysis of human ability to judge visual uncertainty.

The interplay of uncertainty, relevance and learning influences auditory categorization

The interplay of contextual and immediate uncertainty: evidence for a common processing mechanism in prediction and cognitive control

Multisensory transfer effects in implicit and explicit category learning

Orientation Specificity and Generalization of Perceptual Learning in N-Afc Spatial Frequency Identification.

Bottom-up and Top-Down Factors of Motion Direction Learning Transfer.

Evaluating the Performance of the Staircase and Qcd Methods in Measuring Specificity/transfer of Perceptual Learning

Transfer of learned cognitive control settings within and between tasks

Feature Variability Determines Specificity and Transfer in Multiorientation Feature Detection Learning

Flexible structure learning under uncertainty

Perceptual Learning of Orientation Identification in Filtered External Noise: a Test of the Integrated Reweighting Theory (IRT)

Transfer of statistical learning between tasks.