Abstract:Humans do not have an accurate representation of probability information in the environment but distort it in a surprisingly stereotyped way (“probability distortion”), as shown in a wide range of judgment and decision-making tasks. Many theories hypothesize that humans automatically compensate for the uncertainty inherent in probability information (“representational uncertainty”) and probability distortion is a consequence of uncertainty compensation. Here we examined whether and how the representational uncertainty of probability is quantified in the human brain and its relevance to probability distortion behavior. Human subjects (13 female and 9 male) kept tracking the relative frequency of one color of dot in a sequence of dot arrays while their brain activity was recorded by MEG. We found converging evidence from both neural entrainment and time-resolved decoding analysis that a mathematically derived measure of representational uncertainty is automatically computed in the brain, despite it is not explicitly required by the task. In particular, the encodings of relative frequency and its representational uncertainty, respectively, occur at latencies of ∼300 and 400 ms. The relative strength of the brain responses to these two quantities correlates with the probability distortion behavior. The automatic and fast encoding of the representational uncertainty provides neural basis for the uncertainty compensation hypothesis of probability distortion. More generally, since representational uncertainty is closely related to confidence estimation, our findings exemplify how confidence might emerge before perceptual judgment. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT Human perception of probabilities and relative frequencies can be markedly distorted, which is a potential source of disastrous decisions. But the brain is not just ignorant of probability; probability distortions are highly patterned and similar across different tasks. Recent theoretical work suggests that probability distortions arise from the brain's compensation of its own uncertainty in representing probability. Is such representational uncertainty really computed in the brain? To answer this question, we asked human subjects to track an ongoing stimulus sequence of relative frequencies and recorded their brain responses using MEG. Indeed, we found that the neural encoding of representational uncertainty accompanies that of relative frequency, although the former is not explicitly required by the task.

Cue Predictiveness and Uncertainty Determine Cue Representation During Visual Statistical Learning.

Prior probability cues bias sensory encoding with increasing task exposure

Probabilistic retro-cues do not determine state in visual working memory

Spatial Enhancement Due to Statistical Learning Tracks the Estimated Spatial Probability.

Alpha oscillations encode Bayesian belief updating underlying attentional allocation in dynamic environments

Limited evidence for probabilistic cueing effects on grating-evoked event-related potentials and orientation decoding performance

The role of selective attention in implicit learning: evidence for a contextual cueing effect of task-irrelevant features

The pupil dilation response as an indicator of visual cue uncertainty and auditory outcome surprise

The visual statistical learning overcomes scene dissimilarity through an independent clustering process

Cueing spatial attention through timing and probability

The relation between implicit statistical learning and proactivity as revealed by EEG

The Influence of Positions of Cues on Probabilistic Category Learning

Uncertainty-modulated attentional capture: Outcome variance increases attentional priority.

Learning of Uncertain Stimuli Transfers from Criterion-Based to Noise-Based Perceptual Decision, but Not Vice Versa

The Time Course of Attention Modulation Elicited by Spatial Uncertainty.

Neural Representation of Valenced and Generic Probability and Uncertainty

Automatic and Fast Encoding of Representational Uncertainty Underlies the Distortion of Relative Frequency

The Sense of Confidence during Probabilistic Learning: A Normative Account

Contextual cueing in preview search

Initial Uncertainty Impacts Statistical Learning in Sound Sequence Processing