Probe Body and Thermal Contact Conductivity Affect Error of Heat Pulse Method Based on Infinite Line Source Approximation
Gang Liu,Bing C. Si,Ai X. Jiang,Bao G. Li,Tu S. Ren,Ke L. Hu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2136/sssaj2011.0228n
IF: 2.9
2012-01-01
Soil Science Society of America Journal
Abstract:The dual probe (DP) method is a widely used method for determining the thermal conductivity (K), the specific heat capacity (c), and the thermal diffusivity (alpha) of soil, but this method overestimates c, particularly for dry soil. The objective of this study is to examine if the probe body and the thermal contact conductivity (H) lead to biased estimation of the thermal properties by using the DP method. We used the analytical solution for cylindrical heat sources with the finite H value derived by Moench and Evans (1970). For an air-dried sand sample with c = 756 J kg(-1) K-1, the experimental estimated c from the infinite line source (ILS) model for DP units, with the heater needles of 3.175 and 1.27 mm, is 953 J kg(-1) K-1 and 904 J kg(-1) K-1, respectively. For 3.175- and 1.27-mm heater needles, the c estimated by applying the ILS model to temperatures simulated using the Moench and Evans solution is 926 J kg(-1) K-1 and 845 J kg(-1) K-1, respectively. Simulations suggest that both the existing of the finite probe body and H make contribution to the overestimation of c from the ILS model. The overestimation of c increases with the increase in the radius of the heater needle and decreases with the increase of H value. Using ILS could lead to substantial errors in the estimated c of dry soil.