Investigation of precision and trueness of the glucose results from 15 measure systems in 4 domestic factories

LIU Ou,XU Guo-bin,WANG Lan-zhen,XIA Chang-yu,LI Hai-xia,LIU Yan

2010-01-01

Abstract:Objective To investigate the precision and trueness of the glucose results from the domestic kits on different analyzers. Methods To provide 5 levels serum glucose standard reference materials which the target values are assigned by reference methods for 4 domestic glucose kits factories,factories choose analyzers by themselves, they calibrated with factory calibrator and C2 respectively, then measure the 5 levels serum. Results The results of all 15 measure systems variation by factory calibrator calibrated are higher than the results by C2 calibrated; when calibrated by factory calibrator, the variation of 8 measure systems adopt GOD method are higher than the variation of 7 measure systems adopt HK method, there are no difference between the two methods measure systems when calibrated by C2. When calibrated by factory calibrator, Bias of C1 ～ C5 include 15 measure systems are respectively:-2.92% ～ 11.68%、-3.37% ～ 9.79%、-3.75% ～ 8.75%、-3.11% ～ 9.55%、-4.38% ～ 8.28%, there are 3 measure systems bias are beyond the limit of the Europe biological variation total error(5.5%), there are 2measure systems bias are beyond the limit of the U.S.A. criterion analyze total error(6%), there is 1measure system bias is beyond the limit of the CLIA′88 defined acceptable error(10%);When calibrated by C2,Bias of C1 ～ C5 include 15 measure systems are respectively:-1.95% ～ 3.57%、-1.52% ～ 1.85%、-2.72% ～ 2.27%、-1.82% ～ 2.9%、-2.83% ～ 2.19%, 15 measure systems bias are within the limit of the Europe biological variation total error(5.5%) and the half limit of CLIA′88 defined acceptable error(10%). Conclusions The bias of some routine measure systems are larger. Precision and trueness of routine measure systems can be improved by calibrated with serum standard reference materials.