Evaluation for serum glucose standardization in clinical laboratories of Southern China by consecutive 6 years proficiency testing based on JCTLM-recommended reference methods

Xueying Lin,Qiaofang Yan,Yuanyuan Du,Jianbing Wang,Di Huang,Jun Yan,Min Zhan,Pengwei Zhang,Jingyu Cheng,Qiaoxuan Zhang,Xianzhang Huang,Liqiao Han

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/labmed-2024-0037

IF: 0.989

2024-06-19

Journal of Laboratory Medicine

Abstract:The accuracy of blood glucose measurement in clinical laboratories is vital for diabetes diagnosis. Trueness Verification Plan was carried out and analyzed for evaluating the standardization of serum glucose among clinical laboratories. Trueness verification samples were distributed to clinical laboratories for three days measurement, and their target values were assigned by two certified reference laboratories. The relative bias, coefficient of variation (CV), and total error (TE) for each clinical laboratory were calculated and analyzed. Moreover, the Six Sigma metrics and Quality Goal Index were utilized to reflect the measurement quality of the clinical laboratories. The pass rates evaluated by bias, CV, and TE ranged from 45.2 % to 64.8 %, 96.8 %–98.9 %, and 83.9 %–97.1 % over the six years. The matched systems used in clinical laboratories demonstrated better accuracy than the un-matched systems. The pass rate by bias of hexokinase method is 53.1 %–78.6 %, while the glucose oxidase method is 29.2 %–52.2 %. Overall, 74.2 %–85.7 % of clinical laboratories achieved an acceptable level (both σ>3), and 35.2 %–61.4 % of laboratories reached a "world-class" level (both σ>6). The quality for serum glucose measurement has been greatly improved. However, standardization among clinical systems still needs to be further promoted.

medical laboratory technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper aims to address the issue of standardization in serum glucose measurement in clinical laboratories. Specifically, the study evaluates the standard consistency of serum glucose measurements in clinical laboratories in southern China through a six-year Trueness Verification Plan (TVP). The main objectives of the study include:

1. **Measurement Accuracy and Error Assessment**: Evaluate the deviation, coefficient of variation (CV), and total error (TE) of serum glucose measurement results from various laboratories through the TVP, and compare them with the allowable deviation range.
2. **Standardization Level Analysis**: Use Six Sigma metrics and Quality Goal Index (QGI) to reflect the measurement quality and standardization level of each laboratory.
3. **System and Method Comparison**: Compare the measurement accuracy of matched systems (instruments, reagents, and calibrators from the same manufacturer) and non-matched systems; compare the performance of the Hexokinase method and the Glucose oxidase method, the two main methods.
4. **Performance of Different Brands of Biochemical Analyzers**: Evaluate the performance of biochemical analyzers from brands such as Roche, Beckman Coulter, Mindray, Hitachi, Siemens, and Abbott in serum glucose measurement.

Through these evaluations, the study aims to reveal the current state of standardization in serum glucose measurement in clinical laboratories and propose improvement suggestions to enhance measurement consistency and accuracy.