Abstract:1 For a tetrahedral of [SiO4], the asymmetrical vibrations of Si–O should always be IR active. Unfortunately, these modes were assumed to be IR inactive in Refs. [5,6]. 2 In Refs. [5,6], TO modes were calculated and compared with those obtained from IRAS using p-polarized and grazing incidence IR light [3– 6]. However, it is well-established that for dielectric thin films only the TO mode is observed in transmission and reflection IR using normal incident light. On the other hand both the TO and LO modes are observed with grazing incident light, with the intensity of the LO mode increasing with an increase in the grazing angle [10,13–18]. Furthermore, the intensity of the LO mode is enhanced significantly using p-polarized light [16]. For an ultra-thin oxide film on a metallic substrate, the intensity of the LO mode has been shown to be enhanced and the TO mode concomitantly reduced First, in response to the above Comment [1] it is important to consider the following experimental observations: (i) high resolution electron energy loss spectroscopy (HREELS) [2] and infrared reflection adsorption spectroscopy (IRAS) [3–6] show intense asymmetric vibrational modes related to Si–O–Mo (1048 cm 1 in HREELS and 1056–1059 cm 1 in IRAS), whereas no active asymmetric vibrational modes related to Si–O–Si (1176 cm 1 in HREELS and 1200–1250 cm 1 in IRAS) are in evidence for SiO2(1 ML)/Mo(112), (see Fig. 1). These data indicate the absence of Si–O–Si species, i.e. the presence of isolated [SiO4] units [2], or that the axis of the bonding in the Si– O–Si moities are essentially parallel to the substrate surface. Regarding the latter point, however, off-specular HREELS [7] shows no evidence for an asymmetric vibrational feature related to Si–O–Si in SiO2(1 ML)/Mo(112); (ii) ultraviolet photoelectron spectroscopy (UPS) shows only a single feature at a binding energy of 10.5 eV, corresponding to an oxygen species in the Si–O–Mo linkage, with no evidence of a feature at or near 11.5 eV related to the oxygen species in the Si–O–Si linkage [4]; (Note that there should be two oxygen species, Si–O–Mo and Si–O–Si, in the 2-D network.) (iii) a detailed STM investigation of SiO2(1 ML)/Mo(112) [7] shows a single spot in each c(2 · 2) unit and/or four spots (one clearly distinct from the other three) with a (1 · 1) arrangement. In particular the one distinct spot in each c(2 · 2) unit is inconsistent with the proposed 2-D network model but is consistent with the isolated [SiO4] structure.

Atomic Structure Of A Thin Silica Film On A Mo(112) Substrate: A Two-Dimensional Network Of Sio4 Tetrahedra

Atomic Structure of a Thin Silica Film on Amo(112)substrate: A Combined Experimental and Theoretical Study

Structure of Thin Sio2 Films Grown on Mo(112)

Formation of One-Dimensional Crystalline Silica on a Metal Substrate

The structure of monolayer SiO2 on Mo(112): A 2-D [Si–O–Si] network or isolated [SiO4] units?

Interplay Between Theory and Experiment in the Quest for Silica with Reduced Dimensionality Grown on a Mo(112) Surface

Electronic and Vibrational Properties of Ultrathin Sio2 Films Grown on Mo(112)

Thin Silica Films on Ru(0001): Monolayer, Bilayer and Three-Dimensional Networks of [sio4] Tetrahedra.

Reply to comment on “The structure of monolayer SiO 2 on Mo(1 1 2): A 2-D [Si O Si] network or isolated [SiO 4 ] units?”

Surface Science Letters Formation of one-dimensional crystalline silica on a metal substrate

Atomic structure of an ultrathin Fe-silicate film grown on a metal: a monolayer of clay?

Support Effects On The Atomic Structure Of Ultrathin Silica Films On Metals

Growth And Structure Of Crystalline Silica Sheet On Ru(0001)

X-ray Diffraction Studies of Trilayer Oscillations in the Preferred Thickness of in Films on Si(111)

On the electronic structure of MoSi2(OOl) surface

Cross-Sectional Structure Of Tetrahedral Amorphous Carbon Thin Films

Formation mechanism of two-dimensional hexagonal silica on SiO 2 /Si substrate

Structural Properties of Self-Organized Organo-Silicon Macromolecular Films Investigated by Scanning Tunneling Microscopy and X-ray Diffraction

The atomic structure of a metal-supported vitreous thin silica film.

Synthesis of Well-Ordered Ultra-Thin Titanium Oxide Films on Mo(112)

Ultrathin Silica Films: the Atomic Structure of Two-Dimensional Crystals and Glasses.