Nonequilibrium Anion Detection in Solid-Contact Ion-Selective Electrodes

Ryan C. Gettler,Shima Mehregan,Henry D. Koenig,Andie M. Kaess,Matthias J. Young

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acsomega.4c00131

IF: 4.1

2024-03-30

ACS Omega

Abstract:Low-cost and portable nitrate and phosphate sensors are needed to improve farming efficiency and reduce environmental and economic impact arising from the release of these nutrients into waterways. Ion selective electrodes (ISEs) could provide a convenient platform for detecting nitrate and phosphate, but existing ionophore-based nitrate and phosphate selective membrane layers used in ISEs are high cost, and ISEs using these membrane layers suffer from long equilibration time, reference potential drift, and poor selectivity. In this work, we demonstrate that constant current operation overcomes these shortcomings for ionophore-based anion-selective ISEs through a qualitatively different response mechanism arising from differences in ion mobility rather than differences in ion binding thermodynamics. We develop a theoretical treatment of phase boundary potential and ion diffusion that allows for quantitative prediction of electrode response under applied current. We also demonstrate that under pulsed current operation, we can create functional solid-contact ISEs using lower-cost molecularly imprinted polymers (MIPs). MIP-based nitrate sensors provide comparable selectivity against chloride to costlier ionophore-based sensors and exhibit >100,000 times higher selectivity against perchlorate. Likewise, MIP-based solid contact ion-selective electrode phosphate sensors operated under pulsed current provide competitive selectivity against chloride, nitrate, perchlorate, and carbonate anions. The theoretical treatment and conceptual demonstration of pulsed-current ISE operation we report will inform the development of new materials for membrane layers in ISEs based on differences in ion mobility and will allow for improved ISE sensor designs.

chemistry, multidisciplinary

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to solve the application problems of nitrate and phosphate sensors in agriculture and environmental protection. Specifically, researchers hope to improve agricultural efficiency and reduce the impact of these nutrients on the water environment by developing low - cost and portable nitrate and phosphate sensors. Although existing ion - selective electrodes (ISEs) can provide a convenient detection platform, some of the membrane materials they use are costly, and there are problems such as long equilibrium time, reference potential drift and poor selectivity. These problems limit the performance of ISEs in practical applications.

To overcome these shortcomings, this paper proposes a method of constant - current operation to achieve selective detection of anions by using the difference in ion mobility rather than the difference in binding thermodynamics. Researchers have developed a theoretical treatment method for describing phase - boundary potential and ion diffusion, so that they can quantitatively predict the electrode response under the condition of applied current. In addition, they have also shown that under pulsed - current operation, lower - cost molecularly imprinted polymers (MIPs) can be used to manufacture functional solid - state contact ISEs. The MIP - based nitrate sensor is comparable to the more expensive ion - carrier - based sensor in terms of selectivity for chloride ions, and its selectivity for perchlorate ions is more than 100,000 times higher. Similarly, the MIP - based phosphate sensor also shows competitive selectivity for chloride ions, nitrate ions, perchlorate ions and carbonate ions under pulsed - current operation.

These theoretical treatments and proof - of - concept will provide guidance for the design of new materials based on the difference in ion mobility and help to improve the design of ISE sensors. Overall, this paper attempts to improve the performance of existing ISEs in anion detection by introducing new measurement techniques and theoretical models, thereby providing better tools for environmental monitoring and agricultural management.