Numerical Icing Simulations of Cylindrical Geometry and Comparisons to Flight Test Results

Zachary R. Milani,Edgar Matida,Fatemeh Razavi,Kaniz Ronak Sultana,R. Timothy Patterson,Leonid Nichman,Ali Benmeddour,Kenny Bala
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2514/1.c037682
IF: 1.919
2024-03-20
Journal of Aircraft
Abstract:There is growing interest in government and industry to use numerical simulations for the Certification by Analysis of aircraft ice protection systems as a cheaper and more sustainable alternative to wind-tunnel and flight testing. The ice accretion on a cylindrical test article mounted under the wing of the National Research Council of Canada’s Convair-580 research aircraft during a flight test in Appendix O icing conditions was simulated using Ansys FENSAP-ICETM. A multishot simulation with input parameters averaged over the full icing period led to an increased level of liquid catch and ice accretion (by mass), and a broader ice profile when compared to a simulation with shot-averaged input parameters. An additional simulation using Ansys’ proprietary “extended icing data with vapor solution” method for calculating heat fluxes at the icing surface resulted in a broader ice profile in comparison to the classical technique, which produced a similar amount of accretion by mass. No combination of simulation settings, input parameters, and multishot methods tested in this study generated the same level of surface detail observed during flight testing, however, the amount of ice accretion, general location of ice features, and formation processes were in good agreement with the experimental results.
engineering, aerospace
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper focuses on the numerical simulation of aircraft ice accretion, especially on cylindrical geometry, and compares it with flight test results. The aim of the study is to assess and improve the accuracy of using Ansys FENSAP-ICE software to simulate ice accretion on aircraft under real flight conditions. By comparing different simulation settings and input parameters, the authors found that although the surface details in the experiments were not completely reproduced, the simulation showed good consistency with the experimental results in terms of ice accretion amount, location, and formation process. The paper highlights the potential of numerical simulation as an alternative to wind tunnel and flight tests when certifying aircraft ice protection systems, but also points out the complexity and challenges of simulating natural ice conditions, such as the influence of large droplets. In addition, the study validated the simulation results using data collected from the Convair-580 aircraft of the National Research Council of Canada.