Theoretical quantification of ripple effect of delays in network schedules via activity cruciality

Gunnar Lucko,Yi Su,Richard C. Thompson
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.autcon.2021.103789
IF: 10.3
2021-09-01
Automation in Construction
Abstract:<p>Many construction projects suffer delays. Their delay risk exacerbates as projects become larger with more complex schedules, because of the 'ripple effect', the phenomenon that an individual activity delay can spread, accumulate, and quantifiably impact the project finish. Its magnitude depends on the intricate network schedule structure. Yet criticality is currently assessed based on static durations. And the criticality index merely counts occurrences in probabilistic simulation runs without considering an underlying dependency structure. This research therefore establishes a methodology to systematically study and track the dynamic phenomenon of the ripple effect. Its contribution to the body of knowledge is threefold: First, it develops measures that connect the activity and project levels within the structure to quantify the aforementioned ripple effect. Second, it explores cruciality in a variety of schedule structures and concludes that the cruciality is additive on sequential paths and in proportion to their variances on merges of parallel paths. Links other than the default finish-to-start links may cause an activity directionality to change or even be bypassed, which its cruciality will reflect correctly. Third, it substantiates results by simulating a benchmark schedule to give practical suggestions for delay avoidance that consider how the network structure shapes schedule behavior.</p>
construction & building technology,engineering, civil
What problem does this paper attempt to address?