Abstract:A project schedule contains a network of activities, the activity durations, the early and late finish dates for each activity, and the associated total float or slack times, the difference between the late and early dates. Here I show that the distribution of activity durations and total floats of construction project schedules exhibit a power law scaling. The power law scaling of the activity durations is explained by a historical process of specialization fragmenting old activities into new activities with shorter duration. In contrast, the power law scaling of the total floats distribution across activities is determined by the activity network. I demonstrate that the power law scaling of the activity duration distribution is essential to obtain a good estimate of the project delay distribution, while the actual total float distribution is less relevant. Finally, using extreme value theory and scaling arguments, I provide a mathematical proof for reference class forecasting for the project delay distribution. The project delay cumulative distribution function is $G(z) = \exp( - (z_c/z)^{1/s})$, where $s>0$ and $z_c>0$ are shape and scale parameters. Furthermore, if activity delays follow a lognormal distribution, as the empirical data suggests, then $s=1$ and $z_c \sim N^{0.20}d_{\max}^{1+0.20(1-\gamma_d)}$, where $N$ is the number of activities, $d_{\max}$ the maximum activity duration in units of days and $\gamma_d$ the power law exponent of the activity duration distribution. These results offer new insights about project schedules, reference class forecasting and delay risk analysis.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### Problems Addressed by the Paper The paper primarily explores the statistical characteristics and origins of activity duration and total float time in construction project planning. Specifically: 1. **Statistical Distribution of Activity Duration**: - The paper finds that the activity duration in construction project planning follows a power-law distribution $ P(d) \sim d^{-\gamma_d} $, where the power-law exponent $\gamma_d$ varies by project. - This power-law distribution is caused by the historical process of specialization, where old activities are split into multiple new activities, each with a shorter duration. 2. **Statistical Distribution of Total Float Time**: - Total float time also follows a power-law distribution $ P(T) \sim T^{-\gamma_T} $, with the power-law exponent $\gamma_T$ also varying by project. - Although activity duration and total float time are related, the power-law distribution of total float time is primarily determined by the structure of the activity network. 3. **Project Delay Risk Analysis**: - The paper demonstrates through simulations the impact of the power-law distribution of activity duration on project delays. Ignoring this power-law distribution would underestimate the risk of project delays. - On the other hand, the actual distribution of total float time has little impact on project delays. 4. **Reference Class Forecasting (RFC)**: - The paper provides a mathematical proof to explain the effectiveness of the RFC method in predicting project delays and gives an expression for the normalization factor $ z_c $ to better integrate delay data from different projects. - The value of $ z_c $ is related to the number of activities $ N $ and the maximum activity duration $ d_{\text{max}} $. In summary, through data analysis, model construction, and theoretical derivation, the paper reveals the statistical characteristics of activity duration and total float time in construction project planning and proposes a new method to predict and assess project delay risks.

Emerge of scaling in project schedules

Emerge of scaling in project schedules

Activity delay patterns in project networks

Activity networks determine project performance

Theoretical quantification of ripple effect of delays in network schedules via activity cruciality

The probability distribution of project completion times in simulation-based scheduling

The Empirical Reality of IT Project Cost Overruns: Discovering A Power-Law Distribution

Manageable to unmanageable transition in a fractal model of project networks

Deduction of the Bromilow's time-cost model from the fractal nature of activity networks

Scaling Laws in Earthquake Memory for Interevent Times and Distances

Uncovering the fragility of large-scale engineering project networks

POWER-LAW DISTRIBUTIONS BASED ON EXPONENTIAL DISTRIBUTIONS: LATENT SCALING, SPURIOUS ZIPF'S LAW, AND FRACTAL RABBITS

Scaling laws for the movement of people between locations in a large city

Dynamic Probability Analysis for Construction Schedule Using Subset Simulation

Revisiting and modeling power-law distributions in empirical outage data of power systems

Scaling Properties of Urban Facilities

Analysis of temporal structures of seismic events on different scale levels

Power-law Strength-Degree Correlation from Resource-Allocation Dynamics on Weighted Networks

Emergent invariance and scaling properties in the collective return dynamics of a stock market