Abstract:Abstract I study how people understand, reason, and learn about two major tax policies: income taxation and estate taxation. Using large-scale social economics surveys issued to representative U.S. samples and associated experiments, I elicit respondents’ factual knowledge about tax policy and the income or wealth distributions. Most important, I study their understanding of the mechanisms of tax policy and the reasoning that underlies their policy views. In decomposing policy views, I find that support for income and estate taxes is most strongly correlated with social preferences, that is, the perceived benefits of redistribution and concerns around the fairness of inequality and taxation, as well as with broader views of the government. Efficiency concerns play a more minor role. These correlational patterns are confirmed by the experimental approach, which shows people instructional videos that explain the workings and consequences of one of the aspects of tax policy (the Redistribution and the Efficiency treatments) or that bring the two together and focus on the trade-off (the Economist treatment). The Redistribution and Economist treatments significantly increase support for more progressive income or estate taxes, while the Efficiency treatment has no effect. There are large partisan gaps in both the final policy views and at every step of the reasoning about the underlying mechanisms of taxes. Democrats’ and Republicans’ divergences in tax policy views can ultimately be traced back to different normative criteria (social preferences) and views of the government, rather than to different perceptions of the efficiency implications of taxation.

Public Opinion, Policy Tools, and the Status Quo

Understanding Tax Policy: How do People Reason?

Effectiveness, Efficiency and Equity Tradeoffs in Public Programs: A Citizen Experiment

Contrasting Public Perceptions of Government versus Certified Public Accounting Firm Oversight of Relief Packages

The political divide: The case of expectations and preferences

Public preferences about government spending: Partisan, social, and attitudinal sources of policy differences

Ideology, Information, and Social Welfare Preferences

Cutback management strategies and citizen evaluation of government

Status quo bias and public policy: evidence in the context of carbon mitigation

Optimal Policymaking under Yardstick Vote: an Experimental Study

Do Citizens Care About Government Debt? Evidence from Survey Experiments on Budgetary Priorities

Learning to accept welfare-enhancing policies: an experimental investigation of congestion pricing

Public Policy and Constitutional Prescription

Tax Incentives for Charitable Giving as a Policy Instrument: Theoretical Discussion and Latest Economic Research

Do policy instruments that restrict social identity expression increase economic cooperation?

Dynamic Public Opinion: Communication Effects over Time

A randomized intervention to gauge preferred tax rates and progressivity

Should Politicians be Informed? Targeted Benefits and Heterogeneous Voters

Partisanship vs. Principle: Understanding Public Opinion on Same-Day Registration

Should Governments Invest More in Nudging?

The distributive politics of tax expenditures: how parties use policy tools to distribute federal money to the rich and the poor