Abstract:OBJECTIVES: Public expenditure aims to achieve social objectives by improving a range of socially valuable attributes of benefit (arguments in a social welfare function). Public expenditure is typically allocated to public sector budgets, where budget holders are tasked with meeting a subset of social objectives.METHODS: Decision makers require an evidence-based assessment of whether a proposed investment is likely to be worthwhile given existing levels of public expenditure. However, others also require some assessment of whether the overall level and allocation of public expenditure are appropriate. This article proposes a more general theoretical framework for economic evaluation that addresses both these questions.RESULTS: Using a stylized example of the economic evaluation of a new intervention in a simplified UK context, we show that this more general framework can support decisions beyond the approval or rejection of single projects. It shows that broader considerations about the level and allocation of public expenditure are possible and necessary when evaluating specific investments, which requires evidence of the range of benefits offered by marginal changes in different types of public expenditure and normative choices of how the attributes of benefit gained and forgone are valued.CONCLUSIONS: The proposed framework shows how to assess the value of a proposed investment and whether and how the overall level of public expenditure and its allocation across public sector budgets might be changed. It highlights that cost-benefit analysis and cost-effectiveness analysis can be viewed as special cases of this framework, identifying the weakness with each.

Public preferences about government spending: Partisan, social, and attitudinal sources of policy differences

The political divide: The case of expectations and preferences

Fiscal Policy, Government Ideology, and Economic Activity: Evidence from OECD Countries

Divided Government, Fiscal Institutions, and Budget Deficits: Evidence from the States

Income inequality, voters' support for public spending and the size of the welfare state. A simple political model

Social policy, public investment or the environment? Exploring variation in individual-level preferences on long-term policies

Can Preferences for Redistribution Explain the Impact of Austerity on Political Participation? Evidence from the UK

Effects of Conservative Sociopolitical Attitudes on Public Support for Drug Rehabilitation Spending

Spending Levels of Political Parties: An Explanation Based on a Multilevel Analysis

Are government expenditures more cyclical the more they finance the provision of public goods?

The public provision of goods in democracies: Do age and inequality matter?

Sentiments and spending intentions: Evidence from Florida

Public Opinion, Policy Tools, and the Status Quo

Do Citizens Care About Government Debt? Evidence from Survey Experiments on Budgetary Priorities

Size of government and willingness-to-pay for environmental policy: Evidence from a cross-country survey

Contexts of Convenience: Generalizing from Published Evaluations of School Finance Policies

The Heterogeneous Effects of Government Spending: It’s All About Taxes

Policy over party: comparing the effects of candidate ideology and party on affective polarization

A Functional Classification Analysis of Government Spending Multipliers

Social Decision-Making Analysis: a general approach to inform decisions on resources in the public sector

Mass Media as a Source of Public Responsiveness