Stewardship Theory or Agency Theory: CEO Governance and Shareholder Returns

Lex Donaldson,James H. Davis
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/031289629101600103
1991-06-01
Australian Journal of Management
Abstract:Agency theory argues that shareholder interests require protection by separation of incumbency of rôles of board chair and CEO. Stewardship theory argues shareholder interests are maximised by shared incumbency of these rôles. Results of an empirical test fail to support agency theory and provide some support for stewardship theory.
management,business
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about how the corporate governance structure affects shareholder returns. Specifically, the author explores two theories: Agency Theory and Stewardship Theory, which have different predictions regarding the impact of the combination of the roles of CEO and board chair (i.e., the CEO also serving as the board chair) on shareholder returns. - **Agency Theory** holds that, in order to protect shareholder interests, the roles of CEO and board chair should be separated. This is because the CEO may pursue personal interests rather than the best interests of shareholders, resulting in "agency loss". To reduce this loss, incentive mechanisms (such as long - term compensation plans) can be used to align the interests of the CEO with those of shareholders. - **Stewardship Theory** believes that the combination of the roles of CEO and board chair can maximize shareholder interests, because this structure helps the CEO to act more effectively and achieve efficient operation of the company. In this case, the CEO is regarded as a good manager of the company, rather than an opportunist pursuing personal interests. The paper tests the assumptions of these two theories through empirical research, aiming to determine whether the combination of the roles of CEO and board chair will really reduce shareholder returns (as predicted by Agency Theory), or whether it will increase shareholder returns (as predicted by Stewardship Theory). In addition, the study also examines whether long - term compensation plans will affect these results.