On a Stakeholder Model of Corporate Governance

Jonathan M. Karpoff
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3642906
2020-01-01
SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract:I propose a construct to consider the debate over a corporate governance model that emphasizes stakeholder interests. The debate is relevant to the extent that a stakeholder focus prompts different corporate actions than a shareholder focus. I use this construct to consider the benefits and costs of three rationales for a stakeholder focus based on enlightened self-interest, moral imperative, and externalities. Of these, the externalities rationale holds the most promise as a motive for a stakeholder focus. Evidence, however, indicates that the potential benefits are limited to corporate activities for which social costs are not already internalized. Potential benefits must also be weighed against the costs, which include an increased potential for conflict, waste, and managerial self-dealing. I conclude by advocating for the traditional shareholder interests model of governance, with guidance for managers to deviate from this model in limited cases when the external impacts on stakeholders are large.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?