Overcoming Immiscibility Via a Milliseconds-Long “shock” Synthesis Toward Alloyed Nanoparticles
Yonggang Yao,Qi Dong,Liangbing Hu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matt.2019.11.006
IF: 18.9
2019-01-01
Matter
Abstract:In this issue, Rajeeva and co-workers have reported a new strategy using low-power laser heating to trigger precursor supersaturation in the solution phase to synthesize surfactant-free immiscible alloys while simultaneously patterning the nanoalloys onto the substrate in a programmable manner. In this issue, Rajeeva and co-workers have reported a new strategy using low-power laser heating to trigger precursor supersaturation in the solution phase to synthesize surfactant-free immiscible alloys while simultaneously patterning the nanoalloys onto the substrate in a programmable manner. Nanoparticles, with a variety of compositions, sizes, and structures, have been widely employed in many applications for energy, environment, and sustainability. The ability to alloy different elements into a homogeneous solid-solution structure is critical for continuous property tuning and materials discovery, yet remains extremely challenging in immiscible systems, especially when the synthesis is carried out at low temperatures. One specific variable of interest, the elemental composition, particularly in a multi-elemental alloy space, holds great promise for fine-tuning the material's performance matrix.1Yao Y. Huang Z. Xie P. Lacey S.D. Jacob R.J. Xie H. Chen F. Nie A. Pu T. Rehwoldt M. et al.Carbothermal shock synthesis of high-entropy-alloy nanoparticles.Science. 2018; 359: 1489-1494Crossref PubMed Scopus (683) Google Scholar,2Buchwalter P. Rosé J. Braunstein P. Multimetallic catalysis based on heterometallic complexes and clusters.Chem. Rev. 2015; 115: 28-126Crossref PubMed Scopus (564) Google Scholar Unfortunately, conventional synthetic approaches are limited by thermodynamic restrictions, which often lead to immiscible mixtures or heterogeneous structures (e.g., the Rh-Au bimetallic phase diagram, Figure 1A).3Fenton J.L. Steimle B.C. Schaak R.E. Tunable intraparticle frameworks for creating complex heterostructured nanoparticle libraries.Science. 2018; 360: 513-517Crossref PubMed Scopus (184) Google Scholar,4Chen P.-C. Liu X. Hedrick J.L. Xie Z. Wang S. Lin Q.-Y. Hersam M.C. Dravid V.P. Mirkin C.A. Polyelemental nanoparticle libraries.Science. 2016; 352: 1565-1569Crossref PubMed Scopus (265) Google Scholar In the past, overcoming the immiscibility limit in a solid solution has mostly been achieved only by doping the elements at a low margin. However, this type of approach inevitably excludes opportunities to achieve unique physiochemical properties induced by the potential synergistic effect in the previously untapped immiscible region (Figure 1B). In the catalysis community, this synergistic effect is well recognized and commonly referred to as D-band mixing or hybridization between transition metal elements, which can lead to unusual reactivity and selectivity.2Buchwalter P. Rosé J. Braunstein P. Multimetallic catalysis based on heterometallic complexes and clusters.Chem. Rev. 2015; 115: 28-126Crossref PubMed Scopus (564) Google Scholar,5Xie P. Yao Y. Huang Z. Liu Z. Zhang J. Li T. Wang G. Shahbazian-Yassar R. Hu L. Wang C. Highly efficient decomposition of ammonia using high-entropy alloy catalysts.Nat. Commun. 2019; 10: 4011Crossref Scopus (226) Google Scholar,6Batchelor T.A.A. Pedersen J.K. Winther S.H. Castelli I.E. Jacobsen K.W. Rossmeisl J. High-Entropy Alloys as a Discovery Platform for Electrocatalysis.Joule. 2019; 3: 834-845Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF Scopus (278) Google Scholar The fundamental challenge of immiscibility is rooted in elemental dissimilarity. Different atomic size, electronegativity, crystalline structure, electronic structure, etc., may all come into play. In the bulk scale, high-temperature melt mixing followed by a rapid quenching process sometimes permits high entropy alloys or solid-solution synthesis but is not yet available for all alloy compositions.7Ye Y.F. Wang Q. Lu J. Liu C.T. Yang Y. High-Entropy Alloy: Challenges and Prospects.Mater. Today. 2016; 19: 349-362Crossref Scopus (1248) Google Scholar Meanwhile, at the nanoscale, this type of process using conventional heating and cooling steps becomes more difficult to achieve alloy structures due to the extremely short diffusion length. Notably, Hu and coworkers firstly reported a rapid thermal shock technique for the synthesis of multi-elemental, high-entropy alloy nanoparticles with atomically mixed dissimilar elements (PtPdFeCoNiAuCuSn).1Yao Y. Huang Z. Xie P. Lacey S.D. Jacob R.J. Xie H. Chen F. Nie A. Pu T. Rehwoldt M. et al.Carbothermal shock synthesis of high-entropy-alloy nanoparticles.Science. 2018; 359: 1489-1494Crossref PubMed Scopus (683) Google Scholar,8Yao, Y. and Hu, L. (2019). Thermal Shock Synthesis of Multielement Nanoparticles (Patent). US 2019 / 0161840 A1.Google Scholar In a typical synthesis (Figure 1C), the mixed salt precursors are thermally reduced and alloyed into uniform phases using a high-temperature shock (e.g., 2000 K, 55 ms). The subsequent rapid cooling process freezes the nanoparticles into uniform alloys that would otherwise demonstrate particle aggregation and phase separation if cooled slowly. Thus, the milliseconds-scale thermal shock process enables the physical, non-equilibrium synthesis of alloy nanoparticles beyond the solubility limits. In this issue of Matter, Rajeeva et al.9Rajeeva B.B. Kunal P. Kollipara P.S. Palash V. Humphrey S.M. Zheng Y. Accumulation-Driven Unified Spatiotemporal Synthesis and Structuring (US 3) of Immiscible Metallic Nanoalloys.Matter. 2019; 1 (this issue): 1606-1617Scopus (21) Google Scholar report an innovative, low-temperature approach to rapidly synthesize surfactant-free immiscible Rh-Au nanoalloys directly from precursor solutions, which are normally very challenging to achieve (Figure 1A). Similar to a thermal shock method using milliseconds of high temperature for the synthesis of alloys, the reported milliseconds-scale precursor supersaturation induces the ultrafast nucleation and rapid formation of immiscible alloy particles. A milliseconds-scale chemical supersaturation is triggered by laser heating, leading to an ultrafast, non-equilibrium synthesis of immiscible alloys through rapid nucleation with limited atom diffusion in the short timescale, demonstrating a chemical coalescence-driven "shock" synthesis. The supersaturation also promotes the formation of small nanoparticles without using surfactants due to the drastically reduced critical radius of the nucleus and the limited growth time. As shown in Figure 1D, low-power laser heating (0.6 mW/μm2) onto a solution impregnated SiO2 substrate (deposited with Au nano-islands for effective heat concentration) can thermally induce a micro-bubble in the solution that further triggers precursor accumulation, particularly at the vicinity of the three-phase interface of the bubble/solution/substrate. The precursor accumulation leads to instant supersaturation that induces ultrafast nucleation and rapid synthesis of alloy particles (Figure 1E). The use of laser heating in this approach enables high spatial-temporal precision and allows the rapid synthesis of nanoalloys onto substrates in a programmable fashion. For instance, the authors have demonstrated Rh-Au nanoalloy particles patterned in sub-micron linewidths with tunable line spacing (Figure 1F; 2 μm), which allows them to control the nanoalloy loading density. Such a direct synthesis and simultaneous structuring capability is unique and promising for nanoparticle formation where patterning and heterogeneity are required. Due to the precise control over the synthesis time (milliseconds) and patterning position (micrometers), the authors have called this approach a unified spatiotemporal synthesis and structuring (US3) strategy. The key in this "chemical shock" alloy synthesis is the instant supersaturation triggered by the laser-heating-induced micro-bubble trap, which the authors have theoretically explored using a Random Walk model to simulate the flow and concentration of precursor ions in the solution phase (Figure 1D, middle). Their findings demonstrate that Marangoni convection is the key driving force for ultrafast supersaturation (e.g., S = 27) within 10 ms near the three-phase interface. Such a high supersaturation leads to 3 orders of magnitude reduction in both the synthesis time and critical nucleation radius. In addition, as the supersaturation and alloy formation are close to the substrates, the bubble surface repulsion and substrate capillary forces help to anchor these nanoalloys onto the substrates, forming a patterned structure. The synthesized Au-Rh nanoparticles are highly crystalline, as was confirmed by high-resolution transmission electron microscopy, showing an FCC structure with a lattice of ∼0.23 nm (d<111>). In addition, elemental mapping shows the uniform distribution of Au-Rh in the nanoparticle without clear elemental segregation (Figure 1G). Note that isolated Rh particles were also found using this chemical shock synthesis, which arises from the incomplete mixing/solubility of Au-Rh in the alloy. To demonstrate the utility, the Au-Rh nanoalloys were used as catalysts for the reduction of p-nitrophenol, in which a superior catalytic activity was observed compared to mono-metallic Au and Rh control samples (Figure 1H). This catalytic study offers clear evidence of the synergistic effect between Au-Rh in the nanoalloys and the potential advantages of alloy nanoparticles for practical applications. The reported work has demonstrated a promising strategy for the ultrafast synthesis and simultaneous patterning of immiscible alloy nanoparticles directly from precursor solution phases. Looking ahead, several interesting directions deserve further attention. (1) As the process relies on a substrate with Au nano-islands for highly effective thermal bubble formation, the application of the US3 method to more commonly used substrates (e.g., oxide powders and carbon materials) would be intriguing to explore. (2) In the liquid phase, although chemical supersaturation can be easily achieved, future studies may look into better control of the particle size and alloy compositions. (3) The generality of this method to even higher numbers of mixing toward multi-elemental compositions and high entropy alloy nanoparticles should be verified. If successful, this in situ, patternable, ultrafast synthesis method will largely enable the high-throughput synthesis and screening in the huge multi-metallic compositional space toward a variety of applications.1Yao Y. Huang Z. Xie P. Lacey S.D. Jacob R.J. Xie H. Chen F. Nie A. Pu T. Rehwoldt M. et al.Carbothermal shock synthesis of high-entropy-alloy nanoparticles.Science. 2018; 359: 1489-1494Crossref PubMed Scopus (683) Google Scholar,6Batchelor T.A.A. Pedersen J.K. Winther S.H. Castelli I.E. Jacobsen K.W. Rossmeisl J. High-Entropy Alloys as a Discovery Platform for Electrocatalysis.Joule. 2019; 3: 834-845Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF Scopus (278) Google Scholar,10Seh Z.W. Kibsgaard J. Dickens C.F. Chorkendorff I. Nørskov J.K. Jaramillo T.F. Combining Theory and Experiment in Electrocatalysis: Insights into Materials Design.Science. 2017; 355: eaad4998Crossref PubMed Scopus (5354) Google Scholar Accumulation-Driven Unified Spatiotemporal Synthesis and Structuring of Immiscible Metallic NanoalloysRajeeva et al.MatterNovember 6, 2019In BriefThe concept of accumulation-mediated concentration is translated to the nano-/microscale to achieve in situ unified synthesis and structuring of immiscible nanoalloys. The confinement effect, high fluid flow, and site-specific heating at a laser-induced microbubble trap (MBT) results in one-shot RhAu alloying and structuring. Random walk simulations reveal enhanced millisecond-timescale concentration of ions in the MBT. The synthesized and structured RhAu nanoalloys demonstrate enhanced catalytic activity. Our generic strategy can be easily scaled up toward various catalytic and optoelectronic applications. Full-Text PDF Open Archive