Abstract:International Relations scholars have turned to China’s tributary system to broaden our understanding of international systems beyond the ‘states-under-anarchy’ model derived from European history. This scholarship forms the inspiration and foil for this article, which refines International Relations scholars’ conceptualizations of how international hierarchy arose and endured in East Asia during the Manchu Qing Dynasty — China’s last and most territorially expansive imperial dynasty. I argue that existing conceptions of East Asian hierarchy overstate the importance of mutual identification between the region’s Confucian monarchies in sustaining Chinese hegemony. Instead, we can understand Qing China’s dominance only once we recognize the Manchus as a ‘barbarian’ dynasty, which faced unique challenges legitimating its rule domestically and internationally. As ‘barbarian’ conquerors, Manchus did not secure their rule by simply conforming to pre-existing Sinic cultural norms. Instead, like other contemporary Eurasian empires, they maintained dominance through strategies of heterogeneous contracting. Domestically, they developed customized legitimacy scripts tailored to win the allegiance of the empire’s diverse communities. Internationally, meanwhile, the Manchus strategically appropriated existing Confucian norms and practices of tributary diplomacy in ways that mitigated — but did not eliminate — Confucian vassals’ resentment of ‘barbarian’ domination. East Asian hierarchy may have been more peaceful than Westphalian anarchy, but the absence of war masks a more coercive reality where the appearance of Confucian conformity obscured more fractious relations between Qing China and even its ostensibly most loyal vassals.

Communitarian Interpretation of Confucianism and Just Hierarchy

Just Hierarchy between Citizens

Can Pragmatic Confucian Democracy Justify Electoral Representative Government?

Just Hierarchy between States ON THE NEED FOR RECIPROCITY

The Superiority of the Confucian Hybrid Regime Defended

Individual and Unity (Heti): The Generative Structure of Human Relations from the Confucian Perspective

The Multiple Dimensions of Confucian Relational Ethics and the "Way of Being With"

A Revelation of the Confucian Doctrine of the Ethical and Moral Hierarchical Structure

Reviving the Past for the Future?: the (in)compatibility Between Confucianism and Democracy in Contemporary China

The China Model of Development As Solidarity

On Confucian communitarianism

Confucian Communitarian Culture and "east Asian Economic Model"

Contesting the Confucian peace: Civilization, barbarism and international hierarchy in East Asia

Confucian Communalism in East Asia and Liberalism in the West: A Case Study of Confucian Communalism in China and South Korea

The Modernity of Confucianism and Its Relations to East Asian Culture

Confucianism’s Three Links in the Chain of Administering the Community

A Tentative Study on Hierarchical Concepts in Confucian Consanguinity Relations

How Does a Historical System of Meaning Weigh on the Present? Social Representations of Confucianism and Their Role in Young Chinese Lives in the People’s Republic of China

Against Political Equality

Three Kinds of Hierarchies in Confucian tradition:Illustrated by example of Xunzi

Dialectical Relationship between Goodness and Righteousness of Confucianism and Their Option in Practice