Just Hierarchy between States ON THE NEED FOR RECIPROCITY

Daniel A. Bell,Wang Pei
DOI: https://doi.org/10.23943/princeton/9780691200897.003.0004
2020-01-01
Abstract:As the longest continuously active civilization in the world, China has a rich legacy in the written world with libraries and writings that go back three millennia. These libraries offer scholars vast archives to analyze the past. For example, in classical China, political thinkers developed rich and diverse theories on international politics that took the hierarchy between states for granted. We believe that these ancient theories can be mined for contemporary insights, such as the ideal of reciprocity between hierarchical political communities that formed the tributary system in imperial China. Under this system, China guaranteed security and provided economic benefits to tributary states, but regardless of its advantages in the past, this system would be problematic in the modern world. The most obvious reason is that the tributary system, by definition gives, the vassal states a secondary status and is incompatible with the ideal of the equality of sovereign states. However, while there may be a case for paying lip service to equal sovereignty, in reality, states are neither sovereign nor equal. The most viable path toward global peace involves a bipolar world with the United States and China leading two regional state hierarchies that benefit the weaker states.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?