Interactive comment on “ 231 Pa and 230 Th in the ocean model of the Community Earth System Model ( CESM 1 . 3 ) ” by Sifan Gu and Zhengyu

Liu,Sifan Gu,Zhengyu Liu
2017-01-01
Abstract:"Comments: 1) The authors seem unaware of the recent paper by Rempfer et al (2017, EPSL) which describes in detail how Pa and Th are implemented in their 3D ocean model. Their description is more comprehensive and complete in the sense that an interested reader has all information available to carry out the model development in another model. This comprehensiveness is also a hallmark of the earlier paper by Siddall et al (2005, EPSL). The paper here, however, does not provide the detail this reviewer is expecting of a GSMD contribution. The paper needs to take the Rempfer
What problem does this paper attempt to address?