Interactive comment on “Deep Circulation in the South China Sea Simulated in a Regional Model” by Xiaolong Zhao et al

Xiaolong Zhao
Abstract:Zhao et al. presented a numerical study on the spatial characteristics of the deep western boundary currents (WBCs) in the South China Sea (SCS), using an eddyresolving configuration of HYCOM. They addressed the role of Pacific overflow water and enhanced diapycnal mixing in studying the dynamics of the WBCs. The study provides some quantitative model diagnosis which could be useful to the relevant research community, however, I am not convinced that this work brings further insight into understanding the dynamics of WBCs in general or specifically in the SCS, and therefore has limited contribution to advancing the science for this topic. The simulations are more like a model exercise on idealized vertical mixing, although the authors have been trying to compare their results to observations and previous model stud-
Environmental Science
What problem does this paper attempt to address?