Interactive comment on “Size-segregated characteristics of OC, EC and organic matters in PM emitted from different types of ships in China” by Fan Zhang et al

Fan Zhang,Hai Guo,Yingjun Chen,V. Matthias,Yan Zhang,Xin Yang,Jianmin Chen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.5194/acp-2019-363-ac2
2019-01-01
Abstract:The issue discussed in this manuscript is important. If authors could satisfy reviewers and readers on the following major questions, this paper could be considered by ACP. 1. It’s authors’ duty to explain what’s new in this paper compared to several other papers published by the same group, especially the one on Atmospheric Environment 2019. Both titles indicate similar contents. 2. The results were not organized in a clear way which made them very hard to follow. 1) For different particle size bins, what are the chemical component profile? No figure gives a comprehensive component profile. Only the OC/EC percentages compared among bins were provided. Authors failed to touch the whole picture of the "size-segregated characteristics", which should be the most important part of this study. For example, EC and OC were found very
What problem does this paper attempt to address?