Abstract:Global climate models often underestimate aerosol loadings in China, and these biases can have significant implications for anthropogenic aerosol radiative forcing and climate effects. The biases may be caused by either the emission inventory or the treatment of aerosol processes in the models, or both, but so far no consensus has been reached. In this study, a relatively new emission inventory based on energy statistics and technology, Multi-resolution Emission Inventory for China (MEIC), is used to drive the Community Atmosphere Model version 5 (CAM5) to evaluate aerosol distribution and radiative effects against observations in China. The model results are compared with the model simulations with the widely used Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Fifth Assessment Report (IPCC AR5) emission inventory. We find that the new MEIC emission improves the aerosol optical depth (AOD) simulations in eastern China and explains 22–28 % of the AOD low bias simulated with the AR5 emission. However, AOD is still biased low in eastern China. Seasonal variation of the MEIC emission leads to a better agreement with the observed seasonal variation of primary aerosols than the AR5 emission, but the concentrations are still underestimated. This implies that the atmospheric loadings of primary aerosols are closely related to the emission, which may still be underestimated over eastern China. In contrast, the seasonal variations of secondary aerosols depend more on aerosol processes (e.g., gas- and aqueous-phase production from precursor gases) that are associated with meteorological conditions and to a lesser extent on the emission. It indicates that the emissions of precursor gases for the secondary aerosols alone cannot explain the low bias in the model. Aerosol secondary production processes in CAM5 should also be revisited. The simulation using MEIC estimates the annual-average aerosol direct radiative effects (ADREs) at the top of the atmosphere (TOA), at the surface, and in the atmosphere to be −5.02, −18.47, and 13.45 W m−2, respectively, over eastern China, which are enhanced by −0.91, −3.48, and 2.57 W m−2 compared with the AR5 emission. The differences of ADREs by using MEIC and AR5 emissions are larger than the decadal changes of the modeled ADREs, indicating the uncertainty of the emission inventories. This study highlights the importance of improving both the emission and aerosol secondary production processes in modeling the atmospheric aerosols and their radiative effects. Yet, if the estimations of MEIC emissions in trace gases do not suffer similar biases to those in the AOD, our findings will help affirm a fundamental error in the conversion from precursor gases to secondary aerosols as hinted in other recent studies following different approaches.

Interactive comment on “Patterns in atmospheric carbonaceous aerosols in China: emission

Comparison of Secondary Organic Aerosol Estimation Methods

Carbonaceous aerosols in China: Top-down constraints on primary sources and estimation of secondary contribution

Ambient Organic Carbon to Elemental Carbon Ratios: Influence of the Thermal–optical Temperature Protocol and Implications

Exploring the Sources of Light-Absorbing Carbonaceous Aerosols by Integrating Observational and Modeling Results: Insights from Northeast China

Source contributions to carbonaceous species in PM2.5 and their uncertainty analysis at typical urban, peri-urban and background sites in southeast China

Ambient organic carbon to elemental carbon ratios: Influences of the measurement methods and implications

Carbonaceous Aerosols in Megacity Xi'an, China: Implications of Thermal/optical Protocols Comparison

Exploring the Characteristics and Sources of Carbonaceous Aerosols in the Agro-Pastoral Transitional Zone of Northern China.

Interactive comment on “Size-segregated characteristics of OC, EC and organic matters in PM emitted from different types of ships in China” by Fan Zhang et al

Tracer‐based Estimation of Secondary Organic Carbon in the Pearl River Delta, South China

Source Apportionment and Dynamic Changes of Carbonaceous Aerosols During the Haze Bloom-Decay Process in China Based on Radiocarbon and Organic Molecular Tracers

Source apportionment of fine organic carbon (OC) using receptor modelling at a rural site of Beijing: Insight into seasonal and diurnal variation of source contributions

Stable Carbon Isotopes and Levoglucosan for PM2.5 Elemental Carbon Source Apportionments in the Largest City of Northwest China

The Use Of Levoglucosan And Radiocarbon For Source Apportionment Of Pm2.5 Carbonaceous Aerosols At A Background Site In East China

13C signatures of aerosol organic and elemental carbon from major combustion sources in China compared to worldwide estimates

Application of multi-angle spaceborne observations in characterizing the long-term particulate organic carbon pollution in China

Dual Carbon Isotope-Based Source Apportionment and Light Absorption Properties of Water Soluble Organic Carbon in PM 2.5 over China

Spatial and Seasonal Distributions of Carbonaceous Aerosols over China

Regional Modeling Of Organic Aerosols Over China In Summertime

Emission or Atmospheric Processes? an Attempt to Attribute the Source of Large Bias of Aerosols in Eastern China Simulated by Global Climate Models