Abstract:In the realm of quality assurance, the significance of statistical measurement studies cannot be overstated, particularly when it comes to quantifying the diverse sources of variation in measurement processes. However, the complexity intensifies when addressing 3D topography data. This research introduces an intuitive similarity-based framework tailored for conducting measurement studies on 3D topography data, aiming to precisely quantify distinct sources of variation through the astute application of similarity evaluation techniques. In the proposed framework, we investigate the mean and variance of the similarity between 3D surface topography measurements to reveal the uniformity of the surface topography measurements and statistical reproducibility of the similarity evaluation procedure, respectively. The efficacy of our framework is vividly demonstrated through its application to measurements derived from additive-fabricated specimens. We considered four metal specimens with 20 segmented windows in total. The topography measurements were obtained by three operators using two scanning systems. We find that the repeatability variation of the topography measurements and the reproducibility variation in the measurements induced by operators are relatively smaller compared with the variation in the measurements induced by optical scanners. We also notice that the variation in the surface geometry of different surfaces is much larger in magnitude compared with the repeatability variation in the topography measurements. Our findings are consistent with the physical intuition and previous research. The ensuing experimental studies yield compelling evidence, affirming that our devised methods are adept at providing profound insights into the multifaceted sources of variation inherent in processes utilizing 3D surface topography data. This innovative framework not only showcases its applicability but also underlines its potential to significantly contribute to the field of quality assurance. By offering a systematic approach to measuring and comprehending variation in 3D topography data, it stands poised to become an indispensable tool in diverse quality assurance contexts.

Comparison between ASME and ISO standards on surface texture

Survey of measurement methods for surface roughness

Measurement of Aspheric Surface

Error impact analysis and experimental research for absolute testing of spherical surfaces

Status and prospects of surface texturing: design, manufacturing and applications

Optical and XCT Measurement of Additively Manufactured Surfaces

Comparative Measurements of Surface Roughness Based on Template Matching

Texture Feature Similarity-Based Roughness Intelligent Evaluation: A Case Study Applied to Milled Surfaces

Using Wavelet Packet Transform for Surface Roughness Evaluation and Texture Extraction

Classification of Visual Smoothness Standards Using Multi-Scale Areal Texture Parameters and Low-Magnification Coherence Scanning Interferometry

A comparative study of tribological performance of helical gear pair with various types of tooth surface finishing

The Modelling and Simulation of a Rough Surface

Measurement Studies Utilizing Similarity Evaluation between 3D Surface Topography Measurements

Modeling of Normal Contact Stiffness for Surface with Machining Textures and Analysis of Its Influencing Factors

A Survey of the Research on Surface Roughness Measuring Development and Method

A comprehensive review of tool surface texturing in the cutting process

Design Methodology and Application of Surface Texture: A Review

Review of Surface Profile Measurement Techniques Based on Optical Interferometry

Measurement of Device Surface Profile and Roughness

Influence of Different Filtration Methods Application on a Filtered Surface Profile and Roughness Parameters