Abstract:The stress-based criteria have long been adopted as the major guideline in the design of line pipes, but for those under the displacement control, such as pipelines in seismic regions, landslide areas and subsea environment, the stress-based criteria tend to be relatively conservative, instead the strain-based criteria will be more economic and reasonable to use in the pipe design. Hence, the strain-based design methods in different international standards were summarized and compared, as well as their applicable conditions. In view of the different formulas of the ultimate compressive strain of local buckling in the standards of Norway, Canada, etc., calculations of the ultimate compressive strain were conducted under different radius-thickness ratios and design pressures. It is revealed that the Canadian standard expression and Japanese SUZUKI formula are more conservative. To meet the demand of real engineering application, it was suggested that 0.3 t/D (t refers to the pipe wall thickness; D refers to the external diameter of pipes) be adopted as a conservative estimation of the ultimate compressive strain in the absence of design pressure, and that the Canada standard expression be employed while the design pressure can not be ignored. Because the strain-based design process has not been proposed in the Chinese pipeline codes, the work of this paper can serve as a reference for the research in the relevant areas in present China.

Primary structure an important concept to distinguish primary stresses

Primary structure method of stress classification for design by analysis

CONTROLLABLE STRESS ANALYSIS AND DESIGN OF FLAT STEEL RIBBON WOUND PRESSURE VESSEL

Analysis of Controllable Stress Distribution and Optimal Design of Flat Steel Ribbon Wound Pressure Vessel

Optimal Winding Conditions of Flat Steel Ribbon Wound Pressure Vessels with Controllable Stresses

Stresses Controllable Analysis and Optimal Design of Unique High Pressure Vessel Applied in Hydrogen Charge Station

DISCUSSION ON SOME PROBLEMS OF BEAM-STRING STRUCTURES

Discussion on the Implementation of the Primary Structure Method in Design by Analysis

A study of the ultimate compressive strain of local buckling in strain-based design of pipelines

A RESTUDY ON STABILITY OF STEEL BEAMS:HISTORICAL EVOLVEMENT AND DEFICIENCIES OF CHINESE CODE (Ⅰ)

Design Approach of Stiffeners in Extended End Plate Connections and Finite Element Analysis

New Advances In Theory Of Stability Of Steel Structures

Advances in "design by Analysis" Methods for Pressure Vessels

Basic Principles of Concrete Structures

A New Pressure Vessel Design by Analysis Method Avoiding Stress Categorization

A closed-form structural stress-strain relation and implications on plastic design limits in codes and standards

COMPARATIVE STUDY ON DESIGN METHODS FOR LOCAL STABILITY OF HIGH STRENGTH STEEL FLEXURAL MEMBERS IN DIFFERENT CODES

Applied Method for Stress Classification on Design by Analysis

DESIGN THEORY AND CHINESE TECHNICAL SPECIFICATION FOR STEEL ARCH STRUCTURE

Some Viewpoints on Stress Classification

Construction of 3D Primary Structure and Stress Classification of Cylindrical Shell With Nozzle