Comment on the Paper 《study on Nucleation of Bainite Ferrite》 Authored by LIU Zong-chang Et.al

徐祖耀
DOI: https://doi.org/10.13289/j.issn.1009-6264.2012.02.031
2012-01-01
Abstract:Only few literatures concerning bainite formation containing nucleation process were cited in Liu's paper.There is no detailed elucidation of the main point of view of the authors Liu et.al,i.e.the bainite ferrite nucleates at carbon depleted zone in austenite with nondiffusion,non-shear mechanism and the required condition for the formation of carbon-depleted zone.The present author emphasizes that it is impossible to develop solute-depleted zone during the formation of bainite in steels and Cu-alloys through Spinodal decomposition or by segregation of dislocation.It seems that the main point suggested by Liu et.al has been supported neither by advanced theoretical consideration nor by precise experimental result.Accordingly,the calculation of critical nucleus size and nucleation energy in Liu et.al's paper has no significant meaning.Young scientists are encouraged to take further studies on transformation mechanism of bainite.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?