A Study on the Special Relation of Coincidence of Articles
Zhou Guangquan
DOI: https://doi.org/10.14111/j.cnki.zgfx.2010.03.007
2010-01-01
Abstract:The types of lapping of legal provisions in chinese criminal law include not only special relationship,supplemental relationship,absorbing relationship,the relationship of selecting one but also the inclusion relationship.Based on the special consideration of administrative criminal law,there are some differences between the substantially increased special relationship of the special statute and ordinary statute in the economic crime and the special relationship in the traditional theory of Lapping of Legal Provisions.If the nature of the conduct complys with the compositional features of special law,but only because the amount or the quantity can not meet the requirements of the special statute,we can not convict him or her a crime based on the ordinary statute.At this point,we need to consider the legislative default,the principle of the infringement to the legitimate interest,the necessity of making special legal provisions,the concept of constitutive requirements of stereotyping of particular statutes,the substantial methodology of criminal law and other issues.When the conduct constitutes crime according to both the special statute and the ordinary statute,the exclusion relations of Lapping of Legal Provisions exist;When an act is classified as the type of behavior regulated by the special statute,there is no possibility for the application of ordinary statute.There is a relationship of excluding the application of each other between the lapping of legal provisions and the imaginative competing,so we can't apply the lapping of legal provisions to an act when it is classified as an imaginative superposition crime.