INDEPENDENT AUDITING DEMAND DEFICIENCY IN CHINA: CONTRACT EXECUTION ANALYSIS

王兵,辛清泉

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-596x.2009.11.008

2009-01-01

Abstract:This paper argues that demand deficiency is result of low efficiency of securities price system and limitation of third-party execution.Also,price change has little influence on agent benefit adequately in the current auditing environment in China.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Ex ante Uncertainty Risk,Governance Conflicts,and Auditor Choice:Empirical Evidence from China's IPO Market,1998—2004

Chen Jun,Chen Hanwen,Wu Donghui

2010-01-01

Abstract:To understand the economic role played by independent auditing in China's transition economy and evaluate the performance of independent auditing system,it is important to investigate the demand for audit services as well as the evolution of the system. Based on the marketization reform of Initial Public Offering (IPO) in China,this paper examines the issue empirically from both the information demand and the monitoring demand perspectives. We find that,on the one hand,the demand for high-quality auditing increases with the progress of IPO marketization reform. IPO firms with lower uncertainty risk are more likely to select high-quality auditors after the implementation of authorization system. On the other hand,although the governance conflicts between managers and shareholders create the demand for high-quality auditing,the inadequacy of effective market constraint mechanisms results in governance conflicts between controlling and minority shareholders and reduces the demand for high-quality auditing. The ″absentee owner″ problem for the state controlling shareholders further weakens such a demand. Our findings suggest that the demand for high-quality auditing in China's capital market is not likely to increase unless the governance problem associated with controlling shareholders is addressed.
Perceived Audit Quality, State Ownership, and Stock Price Delay: Evidence from China

Jun Chen,Wang Dong,Shuo Li,Yu (Tony) Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/16081625.2016.1208573

2016-01-01

Asia-Pacific Journal of Accounting & Economics

Abstract:We examine the effect of audit quality on stock price delay and whether the effect differs between two groups of Chinese firms: state-owned enterprises (SOEs) and non-state-owned enterprises (NSOEs). Using a sample of 15,019 firm-year observations for Chinese listed firms over the period 2001-2011, we find that firms with Big 4 auditors are associated with less stock price delay and this negative association is weaker for SOEs than for NSOEs. Our findings suggest that high-quality auditors play an important role in the price formation process, in that there is less stock price delay, and this role varies across firms with different ownership structures. Additional analyses show that the audit quality of international Big 4 auditors is perceived to be different from that of domestic Big 4 auditors. The effect of the perceived audit quality on price delay is different for SOEs controlled by the central government compared to those controlled by the local governments. Our study contributes to extant research by focusing on the economic consequences of auditor choices and by emphasizing the importance of recognizing ownership type when conducting audit research.Data availability Data used are from public sources identified in this paper.
Study on Foreign Research about Auditor Quality:The Impact of Demand and Supply

CHEN Jun,MAO Zhi-zhong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.19616/j.cnki.bmj.2008.12.007

2008-01-01

Abstract:In the security market,the quality of accounting information plays an important role in resource distribution and market operation,and it is determined by auditor quality in a large extent.Generally,it is viewed as a beginning point of research on auditor quality that those investigations focus on driving factors on demand and supply aspects of auditor quality.Considering that current research about it is at the initial stage in China,this paper reviews and summarizes synthetically related foreign researches during the late 20 years.On the basis of review,we put forward some advices to the domestic future research.
Board Gender Diversity,Managerial Power and Demand for External Audit

Kuang Xuewen,Chen Jun

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-3448.2011.06.006

2011-01-01

Abstract:According to the theoretical and empirical research,the board of directors is one of the most important mechanisms that control and supervise the managerial opportunism behavior,and the effective board monitoring can help to restrain the financially fraudulent behavior.However,the effectiveness of corporate governance,especially board monitoring,attracted the attention of government and academic scholars in the wake of the corporate accounting scandals such as Enron and WorldCom.From the perspective of the high quality of external auditing demand,this paper investigates the impact of board gender diversity on the effectiveness of board governance.We empirically examines the impacts of board gender diversity and managerial power on the demand for external audit,using the data from the Chinese listed companies during the periods 2002-2006.We use audit fee,Big Ten and Big Four as measures for higher quality of audit demand,and board with at least one female director and proportion of female directors on the boardroom as measures for board gender diversity.After controlling for other known board,firm and industry characteristics,we find that board gender diversity is associated with higher demand for external audit,this indicates that gender diversity in board of directors can help to improve the quality of external audit;however,the positive effect of board gender diversity on demand for external audit exists only when managerial power is lower.These results indicate that it is difficult for female directors to monitor the managers when managerial power is high due to the low degree of board gender diversity in Chinese listed companies.Our paper contributes to the growing literature that provides evidence on the linkage between board monitoring mechanisms and financial reporting and audit processes.More specifically,it extends the literature on the relationship between board characteristics and audit process.Further,this paper adds to the audit quality literature by showing that managerial power is of significant effect on the relationship between board characteristics and audit quality.
Short Selling and Financial Reporting Quality: Evidence from Chinese AH Shares

Haiyan Jiang,Jun Chen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcae.2019.01.001

IF: 2.944

2019-01-01

Journal of Contemporary Accounting & Economics

Abstract:This paper investigates whether the monitoring function of short sale on firms’ financial reporting quality is conditional on the regulatory quality of the markets, and the strength of internal control at firm level. Using data on Chinese cross-listing AH-shares over the period of 2010–2015, we find that short sale restricts accrual earnings management in A-share markets but not in the H-share market. This difference is explained by the relative inferiority of the A-share markets’ regulatory quality, and is accentuated when the cross-listing AH-share firms have weak internal control. Taken together, the results indicate that short-sellers impose strong monitoring on reporting quality when they perceive a great likelihood of managerial expropriation in a weak legal environment, or in firms with weak internal control.
Do Big Auditors Always Perform Better?——Evidence from China's rights issuers and non-issuers

Wang Liangcheng,Han Hongling

2009-01-01

Abstract:This study examines the persistent monitoring effect of big auditors on earnings management of right issuers and non-issuers in the poor institutional setting of China.We argue that, as economic agents per se, big auditors, defined as international big auditors or domestic big10 auditors in China, have incentives to maximize their own utilities.Their utility-maximization behaviors would result in their various audit quality according to a broad variety of earnings management of their clients.Our results support this conjecture.We find evidence that compared to small auditors, big auditors monitor earnings management in the rights issuers more effectively, as earnings management is measured by positive discretionary accruals and absolute discretionary accruals.This monitoring effect of big auditors is significantly stronger for the group with right offerings than that without right offerings, because discretionary accruals and positive discretionary accruals of rights issuers are significantly higher than those of non-issuers.However, the evidence superficially suggests that big auditors don't constrain earnings management of the whole sample firms consisting of both rights issuers and non-issuers more effectively than small ones.
Study on Initial Audit Pricing Discount of China's Public Companies:Evidence from Auditor Switch

Han Hongling,Chen Hanwen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1003-2886.2007.09.011

2007-01-01

Abstract:Initial audit pricing discount can have important public policy implications related with auditor independence.This paper,based on the two competitive theoretical models of DeAngelo(1981) and Dye(1991),empirically tests the pricing behavior of initial audit by using the data of Chinese security audit market of year 2002—2004.The empirical results support the usefulness of CSRC's policy that requires public companies to disclose the audit fee information in their annual reports,the potential audiuor independence problem aroused by quasi rent and pricing discount will be eliminated or mitigated as the audit fee information being disclosed.The empirical results also have an important regulatory implication:we should pay principal attentions to the auditor switch behavior of big public corporations changing their auditor between the small audit firms.
A Structuralist Analysis on the Determinants of Audit Market Structure

Han Hongling,Chen Hanwen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3785/j.issn.1008-942X.2009.02.011

2009-01-01

Abstract:The nature of competition in the market for audits and CPA firms' behavior and performance in this competitive environment are an important topic in audit research area.This paper,based on structuralism,discusses the three determinants of audit market structure:economies of scale,product differentiation and diversification.Possible economies of scale in audit market are due to the ″learning by doing″ effect during the auditor's industrial knowledge accumulating process and certain degrees of asset specificity of industry specialist.Audit product differentiation can include quality differentiation of audit opinion,signaling function differentiation and insurance function differentiation.Consulting services may affect the price and cost of audit services and the whole audit market structure because of the existence of cross-subsidizing between audit and consulting services induced by economies of scope and knowledge spillovers.Current Chinese audit market structure has three special characteristics:decentralization,partition and low concentration.These characteristics are greatly different from that of Western developed audit market,but researchers haven't systematically provided institutional explanations by following structuralism.For this reason,some important research directions in the Chinese audit market are also discussed in this paper.Potential valuable research topics include:(1)Is the competition between CPA firms efficient competition or inefficient competition?(2)What is the impact of the merger of China's CPA firms on audit market structure? Can it lead audit market to higher concentration?(3)What competitive strategy do international ″big four″ apply in the Chinese audit market? Is it a response to the special audit market structure?(4)As Chinese CPA firms become larger and larger,what characteristics will appear in the aspects of economies of scale,product differentiation and diversification?
Right to Employ Auditors, Independence of Auditing and Corporate Governance

Wang Bing

2006-01-01

Abstract:Based on the analysis of the current system, the paper analyzes the mechanism on the right to employ auditors. It points out that it is because the board has the decisive power to employ auditors that causes the ineffectiveness of auditing contract. Therefore, it is necessary that the right to engage auditors be granted to interest-related parties, which can make equilibrium between surplus claim right and controlling right.
Independent Auditing of Certified Public Accountants in Listed Companies in China

刘宇

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-2820.2008.05.001

2008-01-01

Abstract:Firstly,this paper analyses system fountain of Certified Public Accountants(CPA)from corporate governance of listed companies in China.And then we discuss the limitations about the quality of audit which are embodied in motivation of entrusting party and agents and CPA choosing system based on special economic background of Chinese capital market.Finally,we put forward some advices about these issues.
The Status Quo Of And The Reflections On The Information Disclosure Of Listed Companies In China

Ying-Long Zheng,Le Cheng

2011-01-01

Abstract:In the information disclosure of securities, the listed companies employ over-technical professional terms intentionally or unintentionally, which undoubtedly causes extra burdens on the investors, especially those who are lack of professional skills. The abundance of false or dishonest presentations in securities market distorts has distorted the truth of information and seriously attacked the investor's confidence. The selective disclosure of listed companies infringes on the investor's right to equal access to information and therefore is against the principles of fairness, justness and openness in securities market. Besides, the lack of exercisability of responsibility system makes it difficult for the effective sanctions on the acts harming the investor's interests. The paper investigates the status quo and problems on the information disclosure of listed companies in China, examines the practices overseas in the major securities markets and provides suggestions for the regulation on and system construction of the information disclosure of listed companies in China, which is hopefully beneficial to the improvement of the information disclosure of listed companies therein.
A Re-examination of the Auditor Independence in China

Chen Xiao,Chen Wuzhao

2005-01-01

Abstract:In this study,we re-examine CPA independence in China through investigating the relationship between modified audit opinions and the ROE hurdle rates for listing rights and rights offering.Our empirical result shows that CPAs in China have mastered relatively high level of professional skill and begun to say no' to some accounting manipulation practices.However,this independence is very limited.When the firms' fundamental interests,specifically the rights offering,are involved,the most possible choice of CPAs is to be silent.Our empirical evidence also does not support the idea that the size of CPA firm in China can serve as a proxy for the audit quality.
On Factors Affecting the Penalties of Audit Firms by Regulatory Authority: Evidence from Auditing Regulation of Capital Markets in China

CHEN Xiao,QIU Yu-fang,XU Yong-xin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.16538/j.cnki.jfe.2011.06.012

2011-01-01

Abstract:By investigating auditing regulation behavior of China Securities Regulatory Commission(CSRC),this paper finds that the quality of clients and the expertise of audit firms are the important factors that affecting the penalties of audit firms by regulatory authority.Audit firms whose clients have higher average profitability and lower account receivables have less probability of penalties by CSRC.At the same time,audit firms with higher industry concentration are less likely to encounter the penalties by CSRC.The results are robust with or without Big 4 audit firms,and do not vary with measurement methods of variables or regulation mechanisms of CSRC.
THE INDEPENDENT DIRECTOR SYSTEM IN CHINA : WEAKNESSES , DILEMMAS , AND POTENTIAL SILVER LININGS

S. Kang

Abstract:The independent director system in China has many weaknesses. Independent directors might not be truly independent, and they are not always equipped with the necessary information and expertise. The controlling shareholder ownership aggravates problems of the independent director system. Particularly, it is highly likely that the system based on rubber-stamp directors is used to justify corporate policies and transactions in favor of controlling shareholders. Nonetheless, independent directors in China can bring positive effects to society. Some tainted proposals are screened out before submission by corporate insiders to a formal board meeting since independent directors sometimes raise objections during informal sessions or private conversations (independent directors’ “direct deterrence”). Controlling shareholders, due to the concern of revealing negative information to a capital market and enforcement agencies, would not fully demand independent directors to approve egregious transactions (a controlling shareholder’s “selfcensorship”). In addition, regulations on the business role of individuals with government/party or education experience should be carefully reviewed. On the one hand, these regulations can facilitate anti-corruption campaigns that the Chinese government currently pursues. On the other hand, there is no guarantee that alternative groups are more capable, independent, and ethical than the group with government/party or educational experience.

Law,Business
The Audit Committee System and Innovation of Listed Companies' Governance in China

Xie Deren

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1003-2886.2006.07.006

2006-01-01

Abstract:This paper researches the institutional arrangement of accounting affairs control rights within listed companies' existing corporate governance and its deficiency in China,and suggests the improving measures.We document that,in China's existing corporate governance,executives control not only the internal accounting affairs but also the external accounting affairs(i.e.,the independent auditing affairs).As one of the subcommittee of the board of directors,the existing audit committee is not the audit committee of normative nature suggested by Xie(2005b), its nature is close to the audit committee of American style.But the institutional arrangement is not in conformity with the control rights separa- ting and balancing principle regarding accounting affairs control rights in modem enterprises.As a result,the institutional arrangement can't en- sure the independence of CPA auditing.Based on the analyses concerning ineffectiveness of the monitoring function of the board of supervisors in China's existing corporate governance,we suggest that China should innovate the corporate governance.In particular,China should cancel the board of supervisors and establish the audit committee of normative nature,or reform the existing system of the board of supervisors to be in conformity with the audit committee of normative nature.
The Impact of Auditor Liability System on Audit Quality

Tongwen Yue,Yi Hou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.54097/fbem.v10i2.11051

2023-08-14

Abstract:The complexity of business operations and the likelihood that accounting information may be distorted are both rising along with the market economy's quick expansion, which raises the stakes for auditing work. In the process of independent auditing, the purpose of the auditor responsibility system is to control the auditor's numerous audit relationships. To a certain extent, this system can prevent audit risk and lower the likelihood of audit failure, improving audit quality. This paper examines the issues and causes of certified public accountants' audit failure in the auditing process, examines the current issues with the auditor responsibility system, and makes recommendations for enhancing audit quality in light of the administrative penalty decision made by the China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC) on ShineWing China Accounting Firm and the two signatory certified public accountants in 2022. suggestions for raising the quality of the audit.
Economic Dependence and Audit Quality——The Evidence from China's Capital Market

FANG Junxiong

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1671-9301.2007.02.010

2007-01-01

Abstract:Does the audit fee from client bring the economic dependence,and impair the independence of CPA? We give the answer to this question based on China's capital market,and we find no negative influence of audit fee to audit quality.
Buy, Lie, or Die: an Investigation of Chinese ST Firms’ Voluntary Interim Audit Motive and Auditor Independence

Alex G. H. Chu,Xingqiang Du,Guohua Jiang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-011-0804-2

IF: 6.331

2011-01-01

Journal of Business Ethics

Abstract:In the Chinese stock market, special treatment (ST) firms are the firms listed as facing imminent danger of delisting, unless they return to profitability after reporting two consecutive annual losses. Some ST firms voluntarily pay substantial fees to their external auditors to conduct interim audits, which are not required by regulations. In this study, we investigate and find that ST firms that pay for voluntary interim audits report greater discretionary accrued earnings, higher non-operating earnings, and higher returns on assets in ensuing annual reports. As a result, these firms are more likely to return to profitability and reduce their delisting risk. Our results, which contribute to the current debate on auditor independence, appear to be consistent with the possibility that ST firms “buy” external auditors’ cooperation to manipulate earnings when faced with the threat of delisting.
Auditor Selection, Signal Transmission and Optimization of Capital Structure: an Empirical Research on the Listed Companies in China

张娟,李虎,王兵

2010-01-01

Abstract:Does the auditor selection have the function of transmitting signals on the Chinese capital market? The answer is important to the development of the auditing industry and the expansion of the market demanding basis for independent audit.After analyzing the panel data from the year 2001 to 2006,we find the listed companies can transfer different signals to the market by selecting different auditors of qualifications,hence affecting the optimization of the capital structures.And the auditor selection of state-owned enterprises and private-owned enterprises have different marginal effects on their capital structure,the demand for local large scale auditors by the privateowned enterprises is more significant.
The Analysis on the Causes of CPA Audit Failure

Yun-dal Sun,Yanfen Huang,Xiaosong Bi

Abstract:With the rapid development of capital market in China, the occupation of certified public accountant (CPA) has experienced huge growth for decades. CPA has become an essential and important constituent in China’s macroscopic economic. However, in the recent years, the cases of audit failure emerged quite frequently around the world, such as in 2001 the Enron case of the United States that had made the Arthur Andersen’s shut down. Likewise in 2001, YinGuangXia’s case caused ZhongTianQin accounting firm retreated from the historical stage in China. Furthermore, in 2005, KeLong incident broke out, and then in 2006, Deloitte and Touché accounting firm was summoned by China Securities Regulatory Commission (CSRC). All these cases have called very much attention on audit field. This paper will then focus on the main causes of the audit failure. Through case analysis, this paper will discuss the major reasons for the CPA audit failure in China in order to provide further contribution in such analysis.

Economics,Business

INDEPENDENT AUDITING DEMAND DEFICIENCY IN CHINA: CONTRACT EXECUTION ANALYSIS

Ex ante Uncertainty Risk,Governance Conflicts,and Auditor Choice:Empirical Evidence from China's IPO Market,1998—2004

Perceived Audit Quality, State Ownership, and Stock Price Delay: Evidence from China

Study on Foreign Research about Auditor Quality:The Impact of Demand and Supply

Board Gender Diversity,Managerial Power and Demand for External Audit

Short Selling and Financial Reporting Quality: Evidence from Chinese AH Shares

Do Big Auditors Always Perform Better?——Evidence from China's rights issuers and non-issuers

Study on Initial Audit Pricing Discount of China's Public Companies:Evidence from Auditor Switch

A Structuralist Analysis on the Determinants of Audit Market Structure

Right to Employ Auditors, Independence of Auditing and Corporate Governance

Independent Auditing of Certified Public Accountants in Listed Companies in China

The Status Quo Of And The Reflections On The Information Disclosure Of Listed Companies In China

A Re-examination of the Auditor Independence in China

On Factors Affecting the Penalties of Audit Firms by Regulatory Authority: Evidence from Auditing Regulation of Capital Markets in China

THE INDEPENDENT DIRECTOR SYSTEM IN CHINA : WEAKNESSES , DILEMMAS , AND POTENTIAL SILVER LININGS

The Audit Committee System and Innovation of Listed Companies' Governance in China

The Impact of Auditor Liability System on Audit Quality

Economic Dependence and Audit Quality——The Evidence from China's Capital Market

Buy, Lie, or Die: an Investigation of Chinese ST Firms’ Voluntary Interim Audit Motive and Auditor Independence

Auditor Selection, Signal Transmission and Optimization of Capital Structure: an Empirical Research on the Listed Companies in China

The Analysis on the Causes of CPA Audit Failure