A Structuralist Analysis on the Determinants of Audit Market Structure

Han Hongling,Chen Hanwen
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3785/j.issn.1008-942X.2009.02.011
2009-01-01
Abstract:The nature of competition in the market for audits and CPA firms' behavior and performance in this competitive environment are an important topic in audit research area.This paper,based on structuralism,discusses the three determinants of audit market structure:economies of scale,product differentiation and diversification.Possible economies of scale in audit market are due to the ″learning by doing″ effect during the auditor's industrial knowledge accumulating process and certain degrees of asset specificity of industry specialist.Audit product differentiation can include quality differentiation of audit opinion,signaling function differentiation and insurance function differentiation.Consulting services may affect the price and cost of audit services and the whole audit market structure because of the existence of cross-subsidizing between audit and consulting services induced by economies of scope and knowledge spillovers.Current Chinese audit market structure has three special characteristics:decentralization,partition and low concentration.These characteristics are greatly different from that of Western developed audit market,but researchers haven't systematically provided institutional explanations by following structuralism.For this reason,some important research directions in the Chinese audit market are also discussed in this paper.Potential valuable research topics include:(1)Is the competition between CPA firms efficient competition or inefficient competition?(2)What is the impact of the merger of China's CPA firms on audit market structure? Can it lead audit market to higher concentration?(3)What competitive strategy do international ″big four″ apply in the Chinese audit market? Is it a response to the special audit market structure?(4)As Chinese CPA firms become larger and larger,what characteristics will appear in the aspects of economies of scale,product differentiation and diversification?
What problem does this paper attempt to address?