THE INDEPENDENT DIRECTOR SYSTEM IN CHINA : WEAKNESSES , DILEMMAS , AND POTENTIAL SILVER LININGS

S. Kang
Abstract:The independent director system in China has many weaknesses. Independent directors might not be truly independent, and they are not always equipped with the necessary information and expertise. The controlling shareholder ownership aggravates problems of the independent director system. Particularly, it is highly likely that the system based on rubber-stamp directors is used to justify corporate policies and transactions in favor of controlling shareholders. Nonetheless, independent directors in China can bring positive effects to society. Some tainted proposals are screened out before submission by corporate insiders to a formal board meeting since independent directors sometimes raise objections during informal sessions or private conversations (independent directors’ “direct deterrence”). Controlling shareholders, due to the concern of revealing negative information to a capital market and enforcement agencies, would not fully demand independent directors to approve egregious transactions (a controlling shareholder’s “selfcensorship”). In addition, regulations on the business role of individuals with government/party or education experience should be carefully reviewed. On the one hand, these regulations can facilitate anti-corruption campaigns that the Chinese government currently pursues. On the other hand, there is no guarantee that alternative groups are more capable, independent, and ethical than the group with government/party or educational experience.
Law,Business
What problem does this paper attempt to address?