The Independence of Independent Directors:Evidence from Board Voting Behavior

Ye Kangtao,Zhu Jigao,Lu Zhengfei,Zhang Ran
2011-01-01
Abstract:Chinese listed firms are required to disclose the board voting results on management proposals.Using the unique data,we explore the independence of outside directors.We document that only 4% of firms have dissenting directors who vote against management proposals at least once,which is consistent with the claim by Mace(1986) that outside directors are not quite effective.Furthermore,we find that independent directors are more likely to vote against management proposals when firms perform poorly,and when independent directors have higher reputation,have financial or accounting background,and with a longer tenure.We further document that the firms with dissenting directors enjoy higher market value.Our findings suggest that independent directors become more effective during crises,and the monitoring by independent directors improve firm value.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?