Does Independence of the Board Affect Firm Performance?

Wang Yuetang,Zhao Ziye,Wei Xiaoyan
2006-01-01
Abstract:This paper follows the controversy between the agency theory and the stewardship theory in frameworks of boards of directors and corporate performance. Proponents of the agency theory argue that independent directors may impair agency cost and improve firm performance. Oppositely, independent directors will reduce board's efficiency and alleviate companies' financial achievements in views of the stewardship theory. We systematically examine the link between board's independence and firm performance. We find that proportion of independent directors to all directors is positively related to companies' financial performance in both OLS and 2SLS regressions, furthermore, this relation is weaker in companies with poor shareholders' balance and checks than those of normal firms. The results indicate that agency theory is suitable for China's capital market. We also find that reputation of independent directors is benefit to corporate profits. However, we are unable to detect any relationship between performance and independent directors' other characters, such as industrial expertise, political connection and economics and management career.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?