Flexural-Torsional Bucklinq of Cantilevers under Quasitangential and Semitangential Bending Moments: A Paradox

Gen-shu TONG,Lei ZHANG
2010-01-01
Abstract:For the flexural-torsional buckling of cantilevers under bending moments, if the end moment is semi-tangential and the cross-section is a narrow rectangle, the critical moment is twice as much as that of quasitangential end moments. This paper presents a detailed derivation of the buckling moments under three types of end moments, using both the static equilibrium method and the energy method proposed by the authors. Because the semitangential end moment is half of the summation of two types of quasitangential end moments, an intuitive deduction is that its buckling moment should be also the average of two quasitangential critical moments. Finite element buckling analysis used shell elements SHELL63 and solid elements SOLID45 of ANSYS software to predict identical critical moments for all three types of end moments. Therefore the flexural-torsional theory is not in conformity with that of the shell buckling theory and the intuitive deduction. This doubled buckling moment constitutes a paradox within the flexural-torsional buckling theory itself.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?