Abstract:This study, by surveying 584 ordinary and vocational high school students based on 4 moral-dilemma situations designed according to Kohlberg's stories on moral dilemma, moral conflict events, and the cost of complying with moral norms, aims to explore high school students'moral reasoning on the criterion for the seriousness of transgression. The results show the following: in most cases, the students from both ordinary high schools and vocational high schools tend to agree that moral transgressions in a dilemma should be punished severely; the domains of moral conflicts in a dilemma have a significant effect on the students' moral reasoning,that is, when the cost of complying with moral norms is high, the students consider that the transgression in the situation where there are conflicts between morals and personal interests should be g iven more severe punishment than in the situation where there are conflicts between morals; the cost of complying with moral norms has an important effect on the students' moral reasoning, that is, in the situation where there are conflicts between morals and personal interests the transgressors should be given punishment when the cost is high, whereas only vocational high school students observe the difference when there are conflicts between morals; the difference in moral reasoning between these two groups of students mainly lies in two situations( the high-cost conflicts between morals,and the low-cost conflicts between morals and personal interests), where the vocational high school students tend to agree with the punishment of the transgressors' These results reveal the characteristics of moral reasoning from ordinary and vocational high school students in moral-dilemma situations, as well as the significant roles of moral-dilemma events and cost of complying with moral norms in these students'moral reasoning.

The Complexity of Moral Reasoning and Its Types

Moral instinct and moral judgment

Morality in the mundane: Categorizing moral reasoning in real-life social situations

Dilemma of Moral Dilemmas:The Conflict Between Emotion and Reasoning in Moral Judgments

Reasoning in Social Settings

Rules,Moral Evaluation and Legal Reasoning

Review Of Research On Moral Intuition And Moral Reasoning

Valid Reasoning in Ancient China from the Perspective of Modern Logic

Paradox of Irrationality in Practical Reasoning

Reasoning about Moral Dilemma from Ordinary and Vocational High School Students

Moral appraisals guide intuitive legal determinations.

Is the emotional dog wagging its rational tail, or chasing it?

Reasoning in attitudes

The Impact of Reasoning in Learning and Cognitive Processing

Moral Judgments:Rational Processing or Irrational Processing?——A Perspective From Cognitive Neuroscience

Moral Education Through the Fostering of Reasoning Skills

Principles,Rules,and Legal Reasoning

Distinctions, Judgment, and Reasoning in Classical Chinese Thought

When Push Comes to Shove—The Moral Fiction of Reason-Based Situational Control and the Embodied Nature of Judgment

Universality and Cultural Diversity in Moral Reasoning and Judgment

The Theoretical Reasoning of the Life-Moral Education:A Multi-Perspective Investigation of the Relationship between Moral Education and Life