Options of minimally invasive treatment for complicated upper ureteral calculi
WANG Lei,LIU Xiu-heng,QIU Tao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.13329/j.cnki.zyyjk.2012.14.050
2012-01-01
Abstract:[Objective]To compare the efficacy of four kinds of minimally invasive treatment for complicated upper ureteral calculi,study the reasonable treatment option for the patient with complicated upper ureteral calculi.[Methods]The clinical data of 403 patients with complicated upper ureteral calculi in Renmin Hospital of Wuhan University from February 2008 to January 2011 were retrospectively analyzed.The patients were divided into four groups,which included extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy(ESWL) group,ureteroscopic lithotripsy(URL) group,minimally invasive percutaneous nephrolithotomy(MPCNL) group and retroperitoneal laparoscopic ureterotomy(RLU) group.The operation success rate,stone-free rate,incidence rate of complications,hospital stay and treatment cost of four groups were analyzed.[Results]Among 403 patients,78 cases were treated with ESWL,136 cases with URL,103 cases with MPCNL and 86 cases with RLU.The first operation success rate of ESWL group,URL group,MPCNL group and RLU group was 41.0%,71.3%,87.4% and 97.7%,respectively.One month after the operation,stone-free rate of ESWL group,URL group,MPCNL group and RLU group was 69.2%,85.3%,96.1% and 100%,respectively.The hospital stay of ESWL group,URL group,MPCNL group and RLU group was(4.5±1.9) d,(6.5±2.1) d,(9.6±1.9) d and(9.1±2.2) d,respectively.The treatment cost of ESWL group,URL group,MPCNL group and RLU group was(3 947±721) Yuan,(7682±937) Yuan,(12 613±1342) Yuan and(13 284±1 830) Yuan,respectively.The incidence rate of serious complications of ESWL group,URL group,MPCNL group and RLU group was 0,1.5%,1.0% and 0,respectively.[Conclusion]All of four methods can be used for the treatment of complicated upper ureteral calculi.ESWL and URL have shorter treatment time and less damage.MPCNL and RLU have longer treatment time,higher stone-free rate and more costs.The best therapy should be adopted according to the patient's clinic condition and actual demand.