Analysis of Three Treatment Methods for Impacted Upper Ureteral Calculus

龚隽,葛京平,徐晓锋,位志峰,许松,魏武

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1008-8199.2010.08.018

2010-01-01

Abstract:Objective There are many choices in minimally invasive surgery for the treatment of impacted ureteral stones.How to properly evaluate and select the appropriate surgical method deserves further investigation.This article evaluated the application and clinical effects of ureteroscopic lithotripsy(URL),minimally invasive percutaneous nephrolithotripsy(MPCNL) and retroperitoneoscopic ureterolithotomy(RPUL) in the treatment of impacted upper ureteral calculus.Methods We retrospectively analyzed 246 cases of impacted upper ureteral calculus treated in our hospital between August 2004 and November 2009.The patients,aged from 18 to 72(42.1±11.1) years,were assigned to groups A(n=120),B(n=85) and C(n=41) to receive URL,MPCNL and RPUL,respectively.And we compared the three methods in the cure rate,the calculus elimination rate,postoperative hospital stay,and the rate of postoperative complications.Results The cure rates of groups A,B and C were 95.8%,97.6% and 95.1%,with no significant differences among the three(P=0.730);the calculus elimination rates were 70.8%,94.1%,and 92.7%,with significant differences(P0.01),significantly lower in group A than in B and C(P0.01),but with no significant differences between the latter two(P=0.714);the operating times were(25.2±7.6),(75.4±7.9) and(148.7±10.1)minutes,with significant differences among the three and between any two as well(P0.01);the postoperative hospital stays were(5.2±2.2),(6.9±2.5) and(9.6±2.6) days,with significant difference among the three and between any two(P0.01);the rates of postoperative complications were 6.7%,4.7% and 4.9%,with no significant differences among the three groups(P=0.930).Conclusion All the three methods achieved good effects,with no significant differences in the rate of postoperative complications,but their characteristics vary from one another.A proper choice can be made among the three according to the condition of a specific patient.