Comparison of Measurement Performance between Piezoelectric and Differential-pressure Vortex Flowmeters

SUN Zhi-qiang,ZHANG Hong-jian

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3969/j.issn.1000-3932.2007.06.019

2007-01-01

Abstract:To optimize the measurement of vortex flowmeter,compared the effect of piezoelectric and differential-pressure method,based on a series of contrast experiments.The differences between the two methods in vortex frequency measurement,signal amplitude and anti-interference ability were analyzed.The results show that,first,the flowrate values obtained from these two methods are close to each other under the same fixed flowrate,and the relative error of their meter coefficients is 0.3%.Second,the output signal of the piezoelectric method is tightly linked to the flowrate,and its amplitude increases in an approximate quadratic form with the flowrate.The signal amplitude of the differential-pressure method may be distorted due to the dynamic response limit of the differential pressure sensing system when the measured flowrate exceeds a certain value.Third,the piezoelectric method is sensitive to pipe vibration,whereas the differential-pressure method is hardly affected by this kind of disturbance to some extent.