Abstract:The purpose of this study was to compare tract-based-spatial-statistics (TBSS) and ROI-based approach in examining the white matter integrity between AD, MCI, and normal control (NC) subjects who have no obvious WM lesions. Sixty subjects without obvious white matter lesions were selected from a total of 243 subjects by two neuroradiologists. DTI images were acquired with 64 encoding directions using a Siemens 3T MRI scanner. The demographic characteristics were matched among the 3 groups (AD: n = 19; M/F = 7/12, 75.3 ± 5 years; MCI: n = 18; M/F = 9/9, 73.2 ± 3.7 years; NC: n = 23; M/F = 7/16, 73.6 ± 5.9). TBSS analysis was performed with the FSL software package from Oxford's Analysis Group. With the ROI-based approach, fractional anisotropy (FA) was calculated as the standard deviation of eigenvalues from the mean eigenvalue normalized by square norm of eignvalues. With TBSS analysis, no significant differences were found in white matter tracts when AD was compared with MCI and MCI was compared with NC. Relative to NC, AD subjects exhibited significant lower FA values in the neural tracts of corpus callosum body, particularly in its radiations of the forceps major and forceps minor, which are categorically anterior and posterior cingulate fibers, respectively (Fig.1). There were also significant FA differences in the inferior and superior longitudinal fasciculus (p < 0.02). The ROI-based approach showed that the MCI group had significantly lower FA values in parietal WM (p < 0.001) compared to NC; and the AD group had significantly lower FA values in parietal, temporal, frontal WM, parahippocampal and posterior cingulate fibers (p < 0.001 for all). Compared to MCI, the AD group had significantly lower FA values in parietal (p = 0.005), temporal, frontal WM, and parahippocampal and posterior cingulate fibers (p < 0.001 for all). The results may suggest that although TBSS uses WM tract skeleton for spatial normalization, the difference in small areas may be lost. The ROI based analysis uses native image, and may be more sensitive to detect them; however, it is time consuming and not suitable for analyzing differences in the whole brain. More research is needed to improve the group comparison analysis for DTI.

Effect of ROI on Apparent Diffusion Coefficient Quantitative Measurement of Human Brain with FLAIR-DWI

Application of different diffuse gradient direction in human brain to diffusion-weighted image

Effect of region of interest on ADC and interobserver variability in thyroid nodules

ADC Values in Healthy Adult Brain: Measurement and Influencing Factors

Apparent Diffusion Coefficient Measurement in Glioma: Influence of Region-Of-Interest Determination Methods on Apparent Diffusion Coefficient Values, Interobserver Variability, Time Efficiency, and Diagnostic Ability

Angular Resolution Enhancement of Diffusion MRI Data Using Inter-Subject Information Transfer.

Quantification Studies of ADC Value Using 3.0T MR in Normal Rat Brain

Influence of Fluid-Attenuated Inversion-Recovery on Stroke Apparent Diffusion Coefficient Measurements and Its Clinical Application

The effect of ROI size of the vertebral lesion on DWI in the differentiation between benign and malignant lesion by influencing ADC value

Reduced Field-of-View Diffusion-Weighted Imaging in Histological Characterization of Rectal Cancer: Impact of Different Region-of-Interest Positioning Protocols on Apparent Diffusion Coefficient Measurements.

Effects of Regions of Interest Methods on Apparent Coefficient Measurement of the Parotid Gland in Early Sjögren's Syndrome at 3T MRI.

Improving Estimation of Fiber Orientations in Diffusion MRI Using Inter-Subject Information Sharing

Evaluation of apparent diffusion coefficient mappings in amnestic mild cognitive impairment using an image analysis software brain search

A Knowledge Based Automatic Region of Interest (ROI) Segment of Cervical Cord Diffusion Tensor Imaging.

Quantitative Assessment of Breast Tumor: Comparison of Four Methods of Positioning Region of Interest for Synthetic Relaxometry and Diffusion Measurement

Large field diffusion weighted imaging on 3. 0T MR: Initial study

Comparison of Tract-Based Spatial Statistics and ROI-based Approach in Analyzing the White Matter Integrity in the Elderly

Correlation study between ADC values and phase values of normal brain deep nucleus with age

The Effect of Spatial Resolution on the Reproducibility of Diffusion Imaging when Controlled Signal to Noise Ratio

Diffusion Weighted Imaging for Differentiating Benign from Malignant Orbital Tumors: Diagnostic Performance of the Apparent Diffusion Coefficient Based on Region of Interest Selection Method

Comparative study of RESOLVE DWI and conventional DWI in brain MRI