School food and nutrition: developing the evidence base for policy
M. Nelson,J. Breda
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/S1368980013001195
2013-05-21
Public Health Nutrition
Abstract:Worldwide, governments develop policies to improve the welfare of their children, focusing especially on health, education and environmental and social security (1). The basis for these policies is quite often influenced by ideology, but they are tempered partly by the previous experiences of decision makers and the context in which they work, partly by the social and financial environments in which they arise, and partly by the evidence available on the need for and the effectiveness of specific interventions. The quality of the evidence and its interpretation are often contentious, but as time goes by, the accumulation of well-founded evidence becomes a driving force for the development of policy which can be independent of ideological pressures. School food and nutrition provides a good example of these principles. Over a century ago, educationalists recognized that hungry children cannot learn. If one accepts the premise that an educated population is of benefit to a country's development and welfare (2) , as well as the fulfilment of individuals' human capital, it is important that children are well fed with a balanced diet before they arrive at school and during the school day. The initial focus was on the welfare of children from poorer backgrounds, and free or subsidized food was often the norm (3). As school food and nutrition programmes became more established, however , three issues arose. The first concerned the financial viability of school catering services – is school food a public good, to be paid for from the public purse, or should those able to pay be asked to pay? The second concerned the food itself – what food and drink should be provided? Third, how does one measure the impact of school food in terms of educational, health, social and agricultural outcomes? The implementation of school food and nutrition programmes worldwide provides diverse sets of answers to these questions. In some countries, subsidized programmes are linked to local agricultural production and support for families and the workforce, and food provision is based on local staple foods (4) (although in others, it may provide a route for disposing of excess production of particular products) (5). In others, universal provision is paid for centrally through taxation, and food is required to meet nutritional standards and inspected on that basis (6). In yet others, school food is essentially a commercial service, built around an extensive offer of food and drink that children …